"I'm not going to confront anyone." I said it firmly, because I meant it, and because I needed her to believe I meant it. "I'm just going to watch. From my car. Across the street. Before dawn. If a truck comes, I take photos, I send them to Officer Kim, and I do nothing else."
"And if no truck comes?"
"Then I change the locks and move on."
Kate sighed, the long-suffering sigh of a woman who has been friends with me since college. "You call me before, and you call me after. And you do not get out of the car for any reason. Promise me."
"I promise," I said.
I hung up and looked at the lockbox. Then I did the thing I had been turning over in my mind: I put the lockbox back on the side doorknob. I left the old code in it. I left the key in it.
Bait. I was baiting my own house.
It felt wrong, and it felt necessary, and I told myself — the way you tell yourself things at noon on a Tuesday when you've decided to do something slightly reckless — that it was the fastest way to end this.
Chapter 15: Paul's Code
Paul came over that evening with a plate of cookies. Oatmeal raisin. He stood on my porch in his cardigan, holding the plate like an offering, and I felt a complicated twist in my chest, because I liked Paul, and I was about to ask him a question I didn't want to ask.
"How's the renovation?" he said.
"Coming along." I took the plate. "Paul, can I ask you something? About your brother."
His face changed — just slightly, the way a face changes when it's bracing. "Ray? What about him?"
"His company. CleanSlate Hauling." I watched him. "I found one of his invoices in the trash in my house."
Paul went very still. The porch light buzzed. Somewhere down the street, a dog barked once and stopped.
"Julia —" he started, and then stopped, and then started again. "Ray does cleanouts. Evictions, estates. He — he's a good boy, Julia. He wouldn't —"
"Somebody's been dumping trash in my house, Paul. Three times. While I was away. No forced entry." I kept my voice level. It cost me something. "The trash includes mail from 12 Alder Street and an invoice from your brother's company. I need you to tell me the truth about something. Did you ever give Ray a way into my house?"
The silence stretched. Paul looked at the cookies, at the porch railing, at anywhere but me. When he finally spoke, his voice was thin.
"The lockbox," he said. "When you bought the place — the code was in the listing. Ray was doing some work for me, checking — he said he'd check my pipes, and his wrench set was at his yard, and I —" He stopped. His hands were shaking. "I gave him the code from the old listing, Julia. I told him he could cut through your side yard to get to my back fence, and the code, I just — I gave it to him. I didn't think. He's my brother. I didn't think."
I felt the porch tilt under me, the way the kitchen floor had tilted when I found the mail.
"When was this, Paul?"
"January. End of January." He looked up at me, and his eyes were wet. "He said he needed to get to my back fence. The gate was stuck. I swear to you, Julia, I didn't know — I didn't know he was —" He gestured helplessly at my house, at the whole situation, at everything. "He's been cutting corners, I know that. Everybody knows that. But this —"
"Did you know he was dumping?"
"No." It came out fast, almost angry. "No. I knew he complained about the landfill fees, I knew he was always looking for a shortcut, but I didn't know he was — in your house —" Paul's voice broke. "Julia, I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. I'll pay for the locks. I'll pay for everything. Just tell me what to do."
I stood there holding the plate of cookies, looking at this sixty-one-year-old man who had been kind to me since I moved in, who had brought me muffins and told me which plumber to call, and I believed him. I hated that I believed him, because believing him meant the person who let the fox in was someone I liked. But I believed him.
"Paul," I said. "I need you to tell Officer Kim exactly what you just told me. The code, when you gave it to him, all of it."
He nodded, wiping his eyes with the back of his hand. "I will. Tomorrow. I'll go tomorrow."
"And Paul — don't tell Ray. Not yet. Please."
He looked at me, and I saw him understand: the lockbox was still on my door, the code was still the old one, and I was waiting.