He stopped. His hands were shaking a little. The oranges sat on the table between us, bright and ordinary, and a bee moved lazily around the porch rail, and somewhere down the street somebody was mowing a lawn.
"You're right that the door is on you," I said carefully. "And you're right that the crime isn't. I've been thinking about that for weeks, Paul — ever since you told me — and that's where I landed. You didn't know. I believe you. I hate how much I believe you, because it would be easier if you were the villain in this story, but you're not. You're just a man who trusted his brother. That's not a crime. It's barely even a mistake. It's just — sad."
He let out a breath that sounded like it had been held since March. "Thank you," he said quietly.
"Don't thank me yet," I said. "I'm still angry. I'm going to be angry for a while — at Ray, at the whole thing, at the spring I lost to this. But I'm not going to be angry at you forever, because we're neighbors, and neighbors have to find a way. That's the whole deal. That's the only deal there is."
"What did Ray say," Paul asked after a moment, "when you — did you ever talk to him? At the hearing?"
"He didn't say anything to me. He said 'guilty' to the judge and that was it. Eleven minutes."
Paul nodded slowly. "He called me last week. Wanted me to tell you he's sorry."
"Are you telling me because he asked, or because you want to?"
"Both, I guess." Paul picked up an orange and turned it over in his hands. "He's my brother, Julia. He's going to be my brother after the fines and the community service and all of it. I don't know how to hold both things — what he did to you, and that he's my brother. I'm trying to figure it out."
"You'll figure it out," I said. "And for what it's worth — you telling me he said he's sorry? That counts for something. Not everything. Something."
We sat there for a while after that, not talking, peeling the oranges. The juice ran down our chins and we laughed about it, and it was the first time I had laughed with Paul since the winter, and it felt like something being put back where it belonged — not fixed, not forgotten, just put back.
When he left, he stopped at the bottom of the porch steps and turned around. "The locks," he said. "Do they feel different? The new ones?"
"They feel like mine," I said.
He nodded, like that was exactly the right answer, and walked back to his house with the empty orange bag, and I sat on my porch with the peels in a little pile and watched him go, and thought that this — this ordinary Saturday with oranges and an apology — was what the spring had been trying to get to all along.
Chapter 33: The Renovation
With the house clean and locked and mine in a way it had never quite been before, the renovation moved fast — faster than it had any right to, given that I was still working full time for my bookkeeping clients and doing most of the weekend labor myself.
The floors came first. They were original oak under three layers of other people's choices — wall-to-wall carpet from the seventies, then laminate from the nineties, then a sad gray vinyl that the flippers had put down — and the refinishing crew spent four days sanding them down to something pale and honey-colored that made the whole bungalow look bigger and brighter. I came home from a client trip on the last day of sanding and stood in the doorway of the living room with my bag still on my shoulder, breathing in the smell of sawdust and polyurethane, and I thought: this is what the house was supposed to smell like. Not garbage. Sawdust. Newness. The smell of a thing becoming itself.
Then the paint. I had chosen the colors back in January, before any of the trash, in the optimistic first weeks of ownership — and I was stubborn enough to keep them, because the trash did not get a vote on my paint colors. A warm white for the living room and hallway. A soft sage for the kitchen. A deep blue for the bedroom that Kate said would make me feel like I was sleeping at the bottom of the ocean, in a good way. I painted the trim myself on two consecutive Saturdays, taping off the edges with the careful, meditative precision of a woman who needed something to do with her hands that was not sorting through other people's garbage with gloves on.
Kate came over on the second Saturday with coffee and a roller and an expression of deep skepticism.