My House Kept Filling With Trash While It Was Locked — Then I Learned the Truth

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I stood there for a long time. Then I did the thing I am still a little ashamed of: I opened one. It was full of ordinary garbage — coffee grounds, eggshells, junk mail, a broken spatula, takeout containers. Somebody's week, bagged up. Not my week. I did not drink that brand of coffee. I had never ordered from that Thai place — I could see the menu, folded and grease-spotted. The junk mail was for a name I did not know, at an address I did not know, on a street I had never heard of.

Somebody had put their garbage in my house.

I walked through the house then, fast, my heart going like a metronome set too high. Living room: no bags, but the air smelled wrong in there too, faintly. Bedroom: nothing. Bathroom: nothing. Back door: locked. Windows: latched. Front door: I had locked it behind me, obviously, and the deadbolt had been thrown when I arrived — I remembered the particular resistance of it, the way I had to jiggle the key.

No one had broken in. That was the thing. Nothing was forced. Nothing was taken — I checked the laptop, the little box where I kept the good jewelry my grandmother left me, the toolbox. Everything was there. Someone had come into my locked house, left five bags of someone else's garbage in my kitchen and hallway, locked up behind themselves, and left.

I sat down on the kitchen floor — not in a chair, on the floor, next to the bags — and I laughed. It was not a good laugh. It was the laugh you do when your brain has run out of reasonable responses and starts flipping through the unreasonable ones. Then I got up, dragged all five bags out to the curb even though it was not trash day, and scrubbed the kitchen floor on my hands and knees until my knuckles were raw.

While I scrubbed, I told myself a story. It was a reasonable story. I had a friend staying over — no. The bags were mine and I had forgotten — no, I had opened them, they were not mine. Someone had the wrong house — the trash company? No, the bags were inside. Inside.

I finished the floor. I made tea. I sat at the kitchen table with the tea going cold in front of me, and I told myself the most reasonable unreasonable story I could think of: it was a mistake. Somebody — a cleaner, a housesitter I did not have, somebody — had made a mistake. It would not happen again.

I wanted so badly to believe that.

Chapter 5: No Forced Entry

Here is what I did not do, and I want to be honest about it, because it matters later: I did not call the police.

I know. You are already thinking it. Five bags of a stranger's garbage in a locked house and she did not call the police. But you have to understand where I was that Friday night in March, sitting at my kitchen table with cold tea and a just-scrubbed floor. I had owned the house for less than five months. I was still the new person on Dogwood Lane. And the story I had told myself — that it was a mistake — had a powerful undertow, because the alternative was that someone had a way into my house, and I did not want to live in that story. Nobody wants to live in that story.

So instead I did what felt like the responsible version of denial: I investigated, a little, on my own terms. I walked the perimeter of the house with a flashlight after dark, feeling faintly ridiculous, checking every window latch from the outside, looking for pry marks on the door frames. There were none. The frames were old and soft with paint, and any prying would have left a mark you could see from the street. There was nothing.

I checked the side door three times. The lockbox was still hanging on the handle, its little buttons staring back at me. I pressed a random combination and pulled. It stayed shut. I told myself that meant something, though I knew it meant nothing — a lockbox that opens for one code in ten thousand is still a lockbox that opens.

I thought about Paul. This is hard to write, but I thought about Paul. He did not have a key — I had never given anyone a key. I stopped that line of thinking before it finished, because Paul was a sixty-one-year-old retired mailman who brought me store-bought cookies and called me honey, and the idea of Paul hauling garbage bags into my kitchen was so absurd it almost made me laugh again, and I did not want to be a person who suspected her kind neighbor.

What I did, finally, was practical. I made a list. I am a bookkeeper; lists are how I pray. The list said: (1) All doors and windows were locked on arrival. (2) No forced entry anywhere. (3) Five bags, not my brand, not my garbage. (4) Nothing taken. (5) Smell is gone now; floor is clean. And at the bottom, in different handwriting, because I had gotten up to make more tea in the middle: (6) Figure out the lockbox code situation. Soon.

News in the same category

My House Kept Filling With Trash While It Was Locked — Then I Learned the Truth

45 Part