He thanked Reed, and Reed left, and Caleb stood in his yard with the key in his pocket, feeling its small weight against his leg. The marks had appeared in three places now: at the front door, beneath the mailbox, on the rear fence. He did not know what they meant, but he knew they were not accidents. Someone had put them there on purpose, in a sequence, and the sequence felt like a path. He just did not know where the path led, or who had laid it out, or why.
Ruth Bell came to the porch two days later, carrying a plate of lemon cookies. She was eighty-four years old, and she walked with a cane, moving slowly up the steps, her hand steady on the railing. She lived three houses away, in a small brick home that predated most of Willow Creek, a house that had been there when the roads around it did not yet have names. Caleb had known her for years as a neighbor, a quiet woman who kept her garden tidy and who waved from her porch in the mornings, but he had never had a long conversation with her. She had come, she said, because she had heard about the doll, and because she had heard about the marks, and because she thought she might be able to help, though she was not sure how.
Mia met her at the door and showed her a photograph of the symbol on Caleb's phone, holding it up so Ruth could see it clearly. Ruth looked at the photograph, and her hand shook, and she nearly dropped the plate of cookies. Caleb reached out and steadied it, and Ruth set it down on the porch rail with both hands, as if she needed a moment to put something down safely before she could speak. She looked at the photograph again, and then at Caleb, and her face had changed. The polite, neighborly expression was gone, replaced by something older and more serious, a look Caleb had never seen on her before.
"Where did you see that?" Ruth asked. Her voice was quiet, but it had an urgency in it that made Caleb answer at once.
"On our mailbox and fence," Caleb said.
"And the front?" Ruth asked.
"Patricia left it on a piece of paper," Caleb said. He told her about the doll, about the paper beneath the doll's hand, about the key sewn inside the doll's body, and about the marks that had appeared since. Ruth listened without interrupting, her hands folded over the head of her cane, her eyes on his face. When he finished, she was silent for a moment, and then she said, in a voice that was almost a whisper, "That woman has been looking for this for years."
Caleb invited her to sit on the porch, and she did, easing herself into a chair, setting her cane beside her. Jenna brought out glasses of water, and Mia sat on the steps, listening. Ruth began to talk, slowly at first, as if she were reaching back for memories she had not touched in a long time, and then more steadily, as the memories came back to her. When she was a girl, she said, the land around them had not been Willow Creek at all. It had been farms, belonging to six families who worked together as the Brook Creek Agricultural Cooperative. The Monroes had the eastern field. The Bells had the creek. The Harpers had peaches. The Vale family had the old packing warehouse near the railway. There were three other families besides, Greene and Bennett and one more, and together they held the land and worked it and shared what it produced.