She kept cutting. "You found it."
"My camera recorded you."
"I assumed it would."
"What does the symbol mean?"
"You'll understand soon."
"That isn't an answer."
"It is the only one you need."
"You entered my property after two in the morning."
"I stepped onto your porch."
"That is my property."
"Your family has always been protective of things it does not understand."
Caleb lifted his phone a fraction, so that it was unmistakably pointed at her. "I'm recording this," he said.
"Of course you are," she said, without looking up from the rosebush.
"Does the doll belong to you?" he asked.
Her eyes moved toward the phone, just for a second, and then back to her work. "It belonged to my family," she said.
"Then why leave it with me?"
"You should look more closely."
"At what?"
"The place where you live."
The sentence landed oddly, and Caleb turned it over in his mind even as Patricia went back to her clipping, because it was the first thing she had said all morning that pointed anywhere at all. Not at him, exactly, and not at the doll, but at the house, at the place itself, as if the house were a party to this and not merely the stage it had happened on. Caleb thought about his house then, not as a list of complaints, railing and mailbox and shed and door, but as a whole: the oldest structure in the neighborhood, standing before the neighborhood had a name, full of rooms his family had lived in for generations. If Patricia wanted him to look more closely at that, she was asking him to look at something he had lived inside his entire life without ever really examining, and the idea that there might be something to examine, something he had missed, sat in his chest alongside the fear and refused to be separated from it. He wanted to press her, to make her say what she meant, but he could already see, in the set of her shoulders and the steady snip of her shears, that pressing her would only produce another sentence like the last one, another near-answer, and he was not willing to stand on her walkway collecting riddles while his daughter ate cereal across the street wondering what had happened in the night.
She turned back to the rosebush, and the snip of the shears filled the pause that followed. Caleb felt the conversation slipping out of his hands the way it always did with her, not because she shouted or argued, but because she answered every question with a sentence that was almost an answer and left him holding something he could not use. He tried once more, and this time his voice rose, because the one subject he would not let her turn into a riddle was standing in his mind behind every other subject.
"Patricia, if this is some attempt to frighten my daughter," he said.
"Your daughter has nothing to do with it," she said, and she said it quickly, and flatly, and for the first time that morning she looked directly at him.
"Then explain it," he said.
She smiled, but not warmly, a smile that did not reach past her mouth. "Some doors only open for the person standing on the correct side," she said, and she turned back to the rosebush, and the conversation, as far as she was concerned, was over.
Caleb stood a moment longer on her walkway, with the recording still running and the rosebush between them, and then he turned and crossed the street back to his own house, and the ordinary morning sounds of the neighborhood, a car door, a dog barking somewhere down the block, a lawn mower starting up, all sounded slightly off to him, as if he were hearing them from the wrong side of a pane of glass. He stopped the recording at his own front steps and stood there a moment, looking at his porch, at the brick wall where the doll had sat, at the board near the railing that had creaked under Patricia's weight. In daylight the porch looked unremarkable, which was its usual condition, and Caleb found himself resenting that unremarkableness, because it made the night feel less real, and he needed it to stay real. He had the clip. He had the photographs. He had the doll in a bin and the paper with the symbol. He had the recording of the conversation he had just had, in which Patricia had answered everything and explained nothing. That was a good deal of evidence for a morning's work, and it still did not amount to an answer, and Caleb carried that frustration up his own steps like a weight he had agreed to hold for a while longer. Inside, Mia was at the kitchen table eating cereal, her spoon moving in slow circles, and Jenna had told her only that someone had left an old doll on the porch, which was true as far as it went and left out everything that made it matter.