My Neighbor Trespassed Onto My Property and Left a Doll With a Strange Symbol at My Door — I Had No Idea What Her True Motive Was

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He gave his name and his address and told the dispatcher, as plainly as he could, that his neighbor had come onto his porch at 2:13 in the morning and left a doll and a drawing. He heard how it sounded as he said it. He sounded like a man reporting a prank. He also sounded, to himself, like a man who knew there was more to it than a prank and could not yet prove it. The dispatcher took the details without comment and told him an officer would come. Caleb thanked her, set the phone down, and sat at the kitchen table with Jenna while the house ticked and settled around them and the night refused, for a long time, to feel ordinary again.

The forty minutes between the call and the officer's arrival were the longest part of the night. Caleb checked the garage lock twice and the front door once, and then he stopped checking locks, because checking them a third time would not have made them any more locked, and would only have told Jenna how rattled he was. Jenna made tea, though neither of them really wanted it, and they sat at the kitchen table with the mugs going cold between their hands, and they talked in low voices about practical things, because practical things were easier to talk about than the thing itself. They talked about whether to wake Mia, and decided not to, because there was nothing to tell her yet and no reason to give her a night like this one to carry into the morning. They talked about whether Patricia could have meant the doll as some kind of peace offering, and dismissed it almost at once, because peace offerings did not arrive at two in the morning with red ink. They talked about the camera, and about whether to save the clip somewhere besides the phone, and Caleb copied it to his laptop while Jenna watched, and the small act of copying felt like building a second lock on a door that had already been locked twice.

Every few minutes Caleb went to the living room window and looked across the street at Patricia's house. The officer arrived forty minutes later. By then the sky had not lightened, but the first thin edge of the night had worn off. Her windows were dark. No light showed anywhere in it. It sat there the way it always sat, neat and silent, giving no sign that its owner had been on his porch an hour earlier in a coat over her nightclothes. Caleb found that more unsettling than if a light had been on. A light would have meant she was awake and ordinary. The darkness meant she had gone back to bed, or was sitting in the dark, and he could not tell which, and both possibilities bothered him.

Officer Thomas Reed was a man who did his job without hurry and without fuss. He listened to Caleb's account standing in the living room, asked to see the footage, and watched it on Caleb's phone twice, the second time with the sound up, though there was almost no sound to hear: the creak of the board, the soft brush of the coat, nothing else. Then he asked to see the doll and the paper, and Caleb brought the bin in from the garage and opened it on the kitchen table, and Reed examined the symbol the way a man examines something he has not seen before and is not sure he needs to remember. He turned the paper over, looked at the back, set it down, and looked at Caleb.

"Any disputes with this neighbor?" he asked.

Caleb almost laughed. It came out as a short, tired breath rather than a laugh, because the question was so much smaller than the answer. Patricia Vale treated disputes like a hobby other people treated gardening or golf. She chaired the Willow Creek Historical Committee, and she served as vice president of the Willow Creek Homeowners Association, and between those two posts she had found something to object to in almost every visible inch of Caleb's property. She had complained about the original porch railing, saying it did not match the newer homes. She had complained about the cedar mailbox, saying it looked unmaintained. She had complained about the shape of the garden shed and about the color of the front door, and once, at a meeting Caleb still remembered with a clarity he did not enjoy, she had argued that his house should be required to match the newer colonial-style homes around it, as if a house could be required to be younger than it was.

News in the same category

My Neighbor Trespassed Onto My Property and Left a Doll With a Strange Symbol at My Door — I Had No Idea What Her True Motive Was

45 Part