He found himself pausing on the moment she knelt. There was nothing hurried in it. A person sneaking would have set the doll down and gone. Patricia had adjusted it, straightened it, made sure it sat upright, as if the way it sat mattered as much as the fact that it was there. And the look into the camera was the detail he kept returning to, because it refused to fit any story he tried to put around it. If she had not known the camera was there, the look would have been an accident. If she had known, and Caleb was certain she had known, since she had lived across the street from the house for years and had watched him install the thing, then the look was a message, and he could not read it. It was not defiance, exactly. It was not apology either. It was the look of a person who expected to be seen and had decided, in advance, not to care. That decision, made calmly, in the middle of the night, on someone else's porch, frightened him more than haste would have.
Across the hall, Mia's door stood partly open, and Caleb thought about how a creaking board downstairs could wake a man upstairs while his daughter slept on, unaware that a woman had just stood outside their front door holding a doll. The thought of Mia sleeping through it, and the thought of her waking to it, both unsettled him in different ways. He got up quietly, so as not to wake Jenna all at once, and stood in the hallway for a moment listening. The house made its usual sounds: the faint tick of cooling wood, the hum of the refrigerator downstairs, the settling groan of old timber. None of them sounded like footsteps. None of them sounded like anyone still being on the porch. But Caleb did not trust the quiet yet, and he stood there until he was sure the only sounds were the house's own.
"What is it?" Jenna's voice came out of the dark beside him, thick with sleep.
"Patricia," Caleb said.
Jenna pushed herself up on one elbow. "Is she at the door?"
"She left something," he said. "At two in the morning?"
Those were her words, said in the flat, disbelieving tone of a person still half asleep, and Caleb had no better answer than the clip on his phone. He showed it to her, and they watched it together in the blue light of the screen while the house stayed quiet around them. Jenna's hand found his arm. Neither of them said anything for a while. Then Caleb swung his legs out of bed and pulled on his jeans, and Jenna sat up fully, awake now, watching him.
"Don't go out there alone," she said.
"I have to look," he said. "It's on our porch."
He went downstairs in the dark, feeling his way along the banister he had known since childhood, and at the bottom he stopped with his hand on the light panel by the front door. He switched on every exterior light the house had: the porch light, the floodlight over the driveway, the small lamp by the side gate, all of them at once, until the yard stood out in hard white against the night. Then he opened the door.
The doll sat exactly where the camera had shown it, upright against the brick wall, its small hands arranged in its lap, the folded paper still tucked beneath one hand. Up close it looked older than it had on camera. Fine cracks ran across its painted cheeks like the lines in old glaze. Its dark hair, which looked almost human in the lamplight, was tied back with a narrow ribbon. Its yellow dress, covered with tiny embroidered flowers, smelled faintly of cedar and dust, a smell that belonged in an attic or a trunk that had not been opened in years. One eye was still blue. The other had faded to almost white, and that mismatched gaze, fixed somewhere past Caleb's shoulder, made his skin prickle in a way he was not proud of.