Caleb's house was the oldest remaining structure in Willow Creek, and one of only two properties exempt from most association rules, and he had reminded her of both facts more than once. It had been standing for thirty years before Willow Creek existed at all. His grandfather had grown up in it. The railing she objected to was the railing his grandfather had leaned on. The door color she objected to was the color the door had been for as long as anyone in his family could remember. When he had said this to her, she had answered, in the tone of a woman delivering a verdict rather than an opinion, that history was not an excuse for disorder. Caleb had not forgotten the sentence. He had also never found a reply to it that satisfied him, because it was not really an argument. It was a way of saying that the past should apologize for still being visible.
What made the disputes so wearying was not any single complaint. A complaint about a mailbox could be answered. A complaint about a shed could be discussed. It was the accumulation, the sense that every visible inch of his house was being measured against houses that had been built decades later, on land that had once been fields, and found wanting for the crime of being older. He had tried, early on, to treat the complaints as neighborliness gone wrong, as a woman who cared about the look of the street and expressed it badly. He had repainted nothing, because there was nothing to repaint, and he had replaced nothing, because the things she objected to were not broken. Over time he had come to understand that Patricia was not really arguing about paint or wood. She was arguing about whether a house like his belonged in a neighborhood like this one at all, and that argument could not be settled by a paintbrush. It could only be repeated, meeting after meeting, complaint after complaint, until the repetition itself became the point. That was why Reed's question had almost made him laugh. Of course they had disputes. Disputes were the background music of his life across the street. But disputes about a mailbox did not explain a doll at two in the morning, and the gap between those two things was exactly what frightened him.
"We've argued," Caleb said to Reed. "Nothing that explains this."
Reed nodded, and his questions came in the steady order of a man filling in a form in his head. "Did she attempt to enter the house?"
"No."
"Damage anything?"
"Not that I can see."
"Leave a written threat?"
Caleb looked at the paper on the table, at the circle and the three lines and the triangle, and he understood the gap between what the symbol felt like and what it said. "Only that," he said.
Reed picked up the paper again and held it to the light, and Caleb watched him the way a man watches someone else handle a thing he does not understand, hoping the other man will understand it for him. Reed turned it sideways, as if the symbol might read differently from another angle, and then set it down again. Reed was not dismissing the symbol. He was filing it, mentally, in a category he did not yet have a name for, and Caleb recognized the look, because he had been wearing it himself since two in the morning. It was the look of a person confronted with something deliberate and illegible at the same time, and it made Caleb feel, oddly, less alone. At least now someone else had seen it, had held it, had turned it sideways and found it just as unreadable. That did not solve anything, but it moved the problem out of Caleb's head and into the world, where at least it could be looked at by more than one pair of eyes.
Reed considered this. "It may be intended to frighten you," he said.
"That's still harassment," Caleb said.
"It could be," Reed said, and Caleb heard the careful space Reed was leaving in that sentence, the space between what might be true and what could be proved. Reed asked whether Caleb wanted the doll taken away, and Caleb said yes, and Reed shook his head with the regret of a man delivering a rule he did not write.
"Unless it contains something dangerous, it is currently abandoned property," Reed said. "You can dispose of it."
"You want me to keep it?" Caleb said.
"You can dispose of it," Reed said again, and Jenna, who had been standing by the sink listening, spoke up before Caleb could answer.