She thought about the boy who had stood in the yard with a pack on his back, and she thought about the man who had written the letter, and she thought about the difference between the two, and she thought about what a mother owed a son, and what a son owed a mother, and what a crossing owed to either of them. The crossing owed nothing to anyone. The crossing was a piece of work, and a piece of work belonged to the person who did it every day, and she had done it every day for five years, and the money in the tin box was the money the crossing had earned, and it was not a bank, and it was not a gift, and it was not a thing to be sent away in an envelope to pay a debt in a city she had never seen.
But the boy was her son. The boy was the child she had carried and nursed and taught to write, and the man was the son who had left and been silent for five years, and the letter was an asking, and an asking deserved an answer, and the answer had to be an honest one, and the honest answer was the one she had already given herself, sitting at the table, looking at the river: no, not the money. Not two hundred dollars, not twenty dollars, not a cent. The crossing was not a bank. The money was the crossing's, and the crossing's money stayed with the crossing.
But the door was open. The door had always been open. If he came home, if he came to the crossing and stood on the bank and asked to work, the door was open, and the work was there, and the work was honest, and the work would feed him, and the work would teach him, and the work would be his if he did it every day. That was the answer. Not money sent away. Work offered at home. That was the only answer a mother could give that was honest, and the only answer a crossing could give that was true.
She sat at the table for a long time after that, with the letter folded beside the toll book, and she thought about the words she would write, because the words mattered, and a letter written in anger was a letter that could never be unwritten, and a letter written in haste was a letter that would be read in haste, and she wanted this letter to be read slowly, and to be understood, and to be kept. She took out a sheet of paper, the good paper she kept for important letters, and she sharpened her pencil, and she wrote.
She wrote that she had received his letter, and that she was glad to hear from him, and that she was sorry to hear of his trouble. She wrote that she could not send him two hundred dollars, and she wrote why, plainly, in words a man could understand: the crossing was not a bank, and the money in the tin box was the crossing's money, earned one wagon, one rider, one walker at a time, and it had to stay with the crossing, because the crossing was what fed her, and the crossing was what would feed him too, if he came home. She wrote that the door was open. She wrote that if he came to Cottonwood Crossing and asked to work, there was work for him, and a bed, and a place at the table, and a wage, and the river, and the boat, and the cable, and the book, and all of it to learn, if he wanted to learn it. She wrote that she did not blame him for leaving, and that she did not blame him for being silent, and that a son who came home to work was a son who had come home, and that was enough. She wrote that she loved him. She wrote it plainly, the way she wrote everything, because love written plainly was love that could be believed.
She read the letter over twice, and she folded it, and she put it in an envelope, and she wrote his name on it, in her own hand: Leif Dahl, St. Louis. And then she sat for a while longer, with the envelope in her hand, and she thought about whether to send it at all, and she decided that she would, because a letter unanswered was a door closed, and she had never closed a door on her son, not when he left, and not now.
She had written the letter twice, in truth. The first draft she had started in anger, before she had thought it through, and the words had come out hard, and she had read them back and seen her own bitterness in them, and she had torn the sheet in half and burned it in the stove, because a letter written in anger was a letter that would be read in anger, and nothing good had ever come