The second withdrawal was larger, and the third larger still, and by the time I reached the statements from last year, the amounts were no longer small at all. There were payments to a contractor I had never met, payments to a designer whose name I did not recognise, payments for marble, for tiles, for light fittings, for a kitchen island that I had never seen in our kitchen, because our kitchen, for all the money that had supposedly been spent on it, still had the same old cupboards, the same old sink, the same chipped tiles that had been there when I first bought the house. I stood up, with Lily still asleep in my arms, and I walked through the house in the dark, from room to room, looking at the walls, looking at the floors, looking for the renovations that had cost Lily her future. The bathroom upstairs had a new mirror, I thought, and a new towel rail, but the bath was the same bath, the shower was the same shower, and the tiles were the same tiles my first wife had chosen years ago. The kitchen had new handles on the cupboards, I noticed now, small brass handles that must have cost a few dollars each, and a new kettle, and nothing else. Where had the money gone? Where had all of it gone?
I went back to my office, and I looked at the renovation bills that Detective Kim had asked me to bring, the bills Vanessa had left in a drawer in the kitchen, and I compared them, line by line, with the withdrawals from the trust. Some of the bills were real, I could see that, small bills for paint, for plaster, for a plumber who had come to fix a leak in the spring. But the large bills, the bills for tens of thousands of dollars, had no contractor's address, no phone number, no signature that I recognised, and the dates on them did not match the dates of the withdrawals. One bill was dated two weeks after the money had already been taken out. Another was for work that had supposedly been done in a room that did not exist, a room that had never been built, a room that Vanessa had described as a new study, when the only study in the house was the one I was sitting in now, unchanged, with the same desk, the same chair, the same shelves that had been there for years.
I thought about Vanessa then, not with anger, not yet, but with a kind of cold, clear sadness, because I was beginning to understand that I had never really known her at all. I had known the woman she wanted me to see, the woman who laughed at my jokes, who cooked dinner, who held Lily's hand in the park, who told me she loved me, and I had believed her, because I wanted to believe her, because after losing my first wife, I wanted to believe that I could be happy again, that Lily could have a mother again, that our house could be a home again. But the woman who had taken money from a six-year-old child's trust, a little at a time, month after month, and who had covered that child's mouth when she cried, and who had locked my sister behind a wall when my sister found out, was not the woman I had married. Or perhaps she was, and I had simply refused to see her, because seeing her would have meant admitting that I had made a terrible mistake, and that Lily had paid for that mistake, every day, in silence.
I thought about Claire, too, lying in a hospital bed that night, with her wrists bandaged, with a drip in her arm, with a nurse checking on her every hour, and I thought about how she had come to our house yesterday with nothing more than a book and a stuffed rabbit, a birthday present for a little girl she loved, and how she had ended up locked in a hidden room, shouting until her throat bled, because she had tried to protect that little girl. I thought about how Claire had always been the brave one, even when we were children, how she had always stood up to people who were bigger than her, how she had never been afraid to tell the truth, even when the truth was dangerous, and I thought about how I had failed her, too, by believing Vanessa when she said Claire was just angry, by calling her six times and then almost giving up, by not coming to the house sooner, by not listening to Lily sooner.
Lily stirred in my lap then, and she murmured in her sleep, a small, soft sound, and she clutched at my shirt, and I held her closer, and I whispered to her, very quietly, so as not to wake her, "I am here, sweetheart. I am here. Daddy is here. Nobody is going to hurt you again. Nobody is going to cover your mouth again. Nobody is going to tell you not to talk about your mommy again. You can talk about her as much as you want. You can cry as much as you want. I will listen. I will always listen."