After I stepped down, Dr. Angela Foster was called. She walked to the front in her neat dark suit, with her hair in a bun and her glasses on a chain around her neck, and she sat down and folded her hands, and she spoke in the calm, clear voice she used with Lily, the voice that made even hard things sound like they could be understood. She told the jury about her work with children, about the way fear changes the way a child speaks, about the way a child who has been told not to speak will stop speaking even when she wants to, and about the way Lily had come to her, quiet and watchful, and had slowly, over weeks, learned to trust that an adult would listen and would not punish her for what she said.
She told them what Lily had told her, in her own words, as much as a six-year-old could put into words, about Vanessa covering her mouth, about being told the hidden room was where bad girls go, about being afraid to cry because crying made Vanessa angry, about hearing Claire knocking behind the wall and not knowing who it was, and about being afraid that if she told her father, her father would be angry too. She told them that Lily was healing, because her father had believed her, because her aunt had stayed, because the house was safe now, because the wall had been painted white and covered with drawings, and because no one in her life told her to be silent anymore.
"Children heal when they are believed," Dr. Foster said, looking at the jury, "and they heal faster when the people who hurt them are not allowed to hurt them again. Lily is healing. She is drawing again. She is laughing again. She is asking questions again. That is what healing looks like in a six-year-old. It does not look like forgetting. It looks like remembering, and knowing that remembering will not get you punished."
The prosecutor then called Detective Sarah Kim, who told the jury, in plain language, about the investigation, about the bank records, about the notebook, about the way Vanessa and Victor had worked together, and about the way the evidence had led, step by step, to the charges. She did not raise her voice. She did not need to. The facts spoke for themselves.
By the time the lawyers made their closing statements, the afternoon light was coming through the high windows of the courtroom, and I was tired in a way I had not been tired before, tired in my bones, as if I had been carrying something heavy for a long time and had only just realised how heavy it was. Elena leaned over and whispered, "It went well. You both did well. Now we wait." And so we waited, while the jury went out, and while the courtroom emptied, and while Claire and I sat on a bench in the hall with cups of water we did not drink, and while the clock on the wall ticked, and ticked, and ticked.
The waiting was the hardest part. I had thought the testifying would be the hardest part, standing up in front of strangers and saying the worst things that had happened in my house out loud, but the waiting was worse, because there was nothing to do, and nothing to say, and nowhere to go, and my mind kept going back over everything I had said, wondering if I had said it clearly enough, if I had left something out, if I had sounded angry when I should have sounded calm, or calm when I should have sounded angry. Claire sat beside me and did not try to fill the silence, and I was grateful for that, because she knew me well enough to know that sometimes the kindest thing is to sit beside someone and say nothing at all.
Elena came and sat with us for a while, and she told us that juries take time, and that time does not mean doubt, and that we should eat something, and we said we would, and we did not. Detective Kim came by and told us she was proud of the way we had testified, and that Lily would be proud too, when she was old enough to understand, and I thanked her, and I meant it, because without her we would not have had the proof, and without the proof we would have had only our word against Vanessa's, and our word, on its own, might not have been enough.
After what felt like hours, but was probably less than two, the door opened and a court officer came out and said the jury had reached a verdict, and my heart started beating so loudly I was sure everyone in the hall could hear it. Claire took my hand, and Elena put her hand on my shoulder, and we walked back into the courtroom together, and we sat down, and I looked at Vanessa, and for the first time that day she looked at me, and her eyes were red, and her hands were clasped so tightly in front of her that her knuckles were white, and I saw, not the woman who had covered my daughter's mouth, not the woman who had shouted at Lily and locked my sister in a hidden room, but a woman who was afraid, and I felt nothing, not pity, not anger, just a strange emptiness, as if the person sitting there was someone I had once known and no longer recognised.