Detective Kim left Marcus and me with the papers and went to make calls, and while she was gone Marcus told me what he had found in the public records the night before, after I had sent him the photographs. Victor Hale was a real contractor, or at least he had been one once, with a business licence and a small company and a history of doing renovation work in the suburbs north of Chicago. But his company had stopped taking new work three years ago, and the address on his licence was a rented office that had been empty for more than a year. Marcus had found something else, too, something that made my hands go cold when he said it. Victor Hale and Vanessa had known each other before she married me. They had lived in the same neighbourhood when they were younger, and there were photographs of them together at a time when Vanessa had told me she was living alone and working in a restaurant and had no one serious in her life. Marcus did not say the word lover. He did not need to. He showed me the dates, and he showed me the way the payments to Victor had started, and he let me draw the conclusion myself, and the conclusion was that the man who had been taking Lily's trust money was not a stranger at all. He was a man from Vanessa's past, a man she had never told me about, a man she had been paying in secret for years.
I asked Marcus how he knew, and he said he had not known for certain until that morning, until he had seen the pattern in the statements, but that once he saw the pattern he had looked for the connection, and the connection was there, in the old records, in the old addresses, in the way Vanessa's name and Victor's name kept appearing near each other. I asked him what Victor had done for the money, if he had not done work on the house, and Marcus said that was the question Detective Kim would have to answer, but that the money had not gone to materials or labour, and that it had not gone back into the trust, and that it had not gone into our joint account. He said the money had gone to Victor, and to Vanessa, and that was all the papers could tell us for now. I thanked him, and I meant it, and I told him I did not know what I would have done without him, and he put his hand on my shoulder and said I would have done the same for him, and that we would follow this to the end, together, no matter where it led.
When Detective Kim came back into the kitchen, she sat down and told us what she had learned from her own calls. Victor Hale had helped Vanessa design the hidden room. She said it quietly, as if she knew how much the words would hurt, and she waited while I took them in. The hidden room behind the walnut wardrobe, the metal door, the small space where my sister had been locked in the dark, had not been built by accident, and it had not been built by the people who built the house a hundred years ago. It had been designed, recently, by Victor Hale, working with Vanessa, to hide things, and to lock people in. Detective Kim said the work had been done carefully, with a door that looked like part of the wall and a lock that could only be opened from the outside, and she said Victor had been paid for that work, too, though not from the trust, not directly, and that the payment for the hidden room had come from Vanessa's private account, the same account that had been receiving trust money for years. I thought about Claire, locked in that room, in the dark, calling for help, and I thought about Lily, six years old, being told that the room was where bad girls go, and I felt a anger rise in me that was so strong I had to stand up and walk to the window and look out at the street until it passed enough for me to speak again.
I asked Detective Kim if Vanessa had told her any of this, and she shook her head and said Vanessa had not been arrested yet, and that she had not been questioned formally, and that she was still at the house of a friend, waiting, and that the police were building the case carefully, because they wanted it to hold. She said they had enough to ask Vanessa to come in for an interview, and that they would do that soon, but that they wanted the money trail complete first, because the money was the thread that tied everything together. She said the trust, the hidden room, the locking of Claire, and the way Vanessa had treated Lily were not separate things. They were parts of the same story, and the story was about a woman who had been taking money that did not belong to her, and hiding it, and hiding the people who found out about it. I believed her. I had lived in that house for four years, and I had not seen it, and now I could see it clearly, and I could not unsee it.
In the afternoon, Detective Kim took me to the hospital to see Claire. Lily stayed with Marcus, who promised to take her to the park and buy her an ice cream, and I was grateful, because I did not want Lily to see her aunt in a hospital bed, and I did not want her to hear what Claire had to tell me. Claire was awake when I arrived, and she was sitting up, and though she was pale and tired, her eyes were clear, and she reached for my hand as soon as I sat down beside her. The doctor had said she was dehydrated and frightened and bruised, but that she would recover, and that she needed rest and quiet and time, and I told her she could have all of those things, and that she was safe now, and that no one would lock her in a room again. She squeezed my hand, and she said she had something to tell me, something she had not told Detective Kim yet, because she had only just remembered it clearly, and she wanted me to hear it first.