My Stepmother Silenced My Daughter — Then Three Knocks Came From Behind the Hidden Wall

Chapter 42

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The letter was short, and it was not what I expected. Vanessa did not ask for forgiveness, not directly. She did not ask to see Lily, not yet. She said she was sorry, for the money, for the room, for the silence, for the nights Lily had spent behind a wall, listening to the house, and wondering if anyone would hear her. She said she had been wrong, about many things, and that she had spent the months in prison thinking about what she had done, and that she did not expect Lily to forgive her, and that she did not expect me to forgive her either. She said only that she wanted Lily to know, if she ever wanted to know, that Vanessa was sorry, and that she would understand if Lily never wanted to see her again.

I took the letter to Dr. Angela Foster, and I read it to her, in her office, with the door closed, and with Lily waiting in the waiting room, drawing, as she always did when we came. Dr. Foster listened, and she asked me what I thought, and I told her I did not know what to think, and she said that was all right, and that I did not have to know yet, and that what mattered was what Lily thought, when she was ready to hear it.

We waited. We did not read the letter to Lily that day, or the next day, or the next week. We waited until Lily asked, in her own way, about Vanessa, about where she was, about whether she was sorry, about whether she would ever come back. She asked, one evening, while we were washing dishes, in the way children ask difficult questions, as if they are asking about something ordinary, like the weather, or like what is for dinner. She said, "Dad, is Vanessa sorry?" I said yes, I thought she was. I said she had written a letter, and that the letter said she was sorry, and that she understood if Lily did not want to see her.

Lily was quiet for a moment, and then she said she wanted to hear the letter. I read it to her, slowly, in the kitchen, with Claire sitting beside her, and with Dr. Foster's advice in my mind, which was to read it plainly, without adding anything, without taking anything away, and to let Lily decide what it meant. Lily listened, all the way through, without interrupting, and when I finished, she was quiet for a long time, and then she said, "I forgive her, Dad. But I don't want to see her yet."

I said that was all right. I said forgiveness did not have to mean seeing someone, and that not wanting to see someone did not mean she had not forgiven them. I said she could change her mind, one day, if she wanted to, and that she could also not change her mind, and that either choice would be hers, and that I would support it. Lily nodded, and she went back to her drawing, and she did not mention the letter again for a long time, and I did not mention it either, except to tell Elena, and to tell Dr. Foster, and to write it down in the notebook I kept, so that I would remember what Lily had said, in her own words, on that evening, in our kitchen, in our house, where she could speak.

Vanessa stayed in prison. Victor Hale stayed in prison too, in a different place, for theft and conspiracy, and I did not think about him often, except when Elena called to tell me about the repayments, and about the paperwork, and about the dates when the next instalment was due. I did not hate him, not in the way I had hated him in the first weeks after the trial. I did not think about him at all, most days. I thought about Lily, and about Claire, and about the house, and about the art room, and about the drawings on the white wall, and that was enough.

The spring after the letter, Lily's school held an art show, and her teacher, Mrs. Patel, asked if Lily would like to put up three of her drawings. Lily chose carefully, taking a whole evening to decide, laying the drawings out on the floor of the art room, and looking at them from different angles, as if she were a curator, not a seven-year-old. She chose the drawing of our house, with the windows too big, and the drawing of the garden, with the sunflowers taller than she was, and the drawing of the three hands, with the words underneath, "I am here. I am here. I am here."

Mrs. Patel did not ask what the third drawing meant. She looked at it, and she looked at Lily, and she said it was a very brave drawing, and that she was glad Lily had chosen it. On the night of the show, the school hall was full of parents and children, and the walls were covered with drawings, and Lily stood in front of hers, in a dress Claire had helped her choose, with her hair in a braid, and she answered questions about her drawings, in a clear voice, without looking at the floor.

News in the same category

My Stepmother Silenced My Daughter — Then Three Knocks Came From Behind the Hidden Wall

45 Part