My father had set up the trust when Lily was born, with enough money to make sure she would never have to worry about school, or about a home, or about the kind of choices that money can make easier. He had named me as the trustee, and he had named Vanessa as the guardian of the money if anything happened to me, because at the time, he had believed Vanessa was a good person, and a good stepmother, and a good partner for his son. He had been wrong about her, and I had been wrong about her too, and we had both paid for that mistake, in different ways.
I thought about my father often, in the year after the trial, more often than I had thought about him in the years since he died. I thought about the house he had built, and the wall he had not known was there, and the wardrobe he had bought, not knowing what it would be used for. I thought about the way he had taught me to fix things, to take a broken chair apart and put it back together, to listen for the sound a house makes when it is settling, to know the difference between a house that is old and a house that is hiding something.
I had used the house well, in the end. That was what I wanted to tell him, and what I had not yet found the right moment to say, until the autumn, when the leaves were turning, and Lily asked if we could visit his grave, and Claire said yes, and we drove to the cemetery together, with flowers from the garden, and with Lily holding a drawing she had made for him.
The cemetery was quiet, in the way cemeteries are quiet, with the grass still green and the trees just beginning to lose their leaves. My father's stone was simple, with his name and his dates, and with a small carving of a house, which I had chosen, because he had built houses, and because he had believed a house should be a place where a child could speak. Lily put her drawing down in front of the stone, carefully, so that the wind would not take it, and she stood back, and she looked at it, and she looked at me, and she said, "Do you think he likes it?"
I said yes, I thought he did. I said he would have liked the colours, and the way she had drawn the house with the windows too big, and the sun in the corner. I said he would have liked that she had drawn it herself, without help, and that she had brought it to him, instead of hiding it away. Claire put her hand on Lily's shoulder, and she did not say anything, and I was glad, because there was nothing that needed to be said, not in that moment.
I told my father, quietly, so that only Lily and Claire could hear me, that I had used the house well. I told him the hidden room was gone, and the wall was white now, and the wardrobe was gone, and the money was back where it belonged, as much of it as we could get back. I told him Lily was safe, and that she was learning to speak, and that she wanted to be a teacher when she grew up, to help children who were afraid to speak. I told him I was sorry I had not seen what was happening sooner, and that I would spend the rest of my life making sure I saw it, in my house, and in other houses, and in any place where a child might be learning to be quiet when she should be learning to be heard.
Lily, who had been listening, took my hand, and she said, "Dad, it's all right. You heard me in the end." She said it simply, without anger, without sadness, just as a fact, and I believed her, because she was right. I had heard her in the end. I had heard three knocks from behind a hidden wall, and I had not stopped until I found out where they were coming from, and I had not stopped until the wall came down.
We stayed at the grave for a while longer, until Lily said she was cold, and Claire said we should go home, and we drove back through Winnetka, past the school, past the park, past the houses that looked, from the outside, like ordinary houses, and that might have been ordinary houses, or might not have been. I did not think about that, not in the way I used to. I thought about dinner, and about homework, and about the drawing Lily wanted to finish that evening, a drawing of three people, her father, her aunt, and herself, with a wall behind them that was white, not hidden.
The letter from Vanessa came in the winter, in a plain envelope, with a prison stamp on it, and with Lily's name written on the front, in handwriting I recognised at once. I held it for a long time before I opened it, standing in the kitchen, with the envelope in my hands, and with Lily in the next room, drawing, and with Claire on the phone, talking to Elena about the trust. I did not want to open it. I did not want to read it. I did not want to know what Vanessa had to say, after everything she had done.
But I opened it, because it was addressed to Lily, and because Lily had a right to know it existed, and because I had promised myself, and Dr. Angela Foster, and Claire, that I would not make decisions for Lily about the people who had hurt her, without giving her a chance to decide for herself, when she was ready.