Michael felt something in his chest go very quiet.
"Today she had to go for tests." Ethan's voice was thick, half-swallowed. "St.
Catherine's. It's four blocks." He lifted his head then, and his face was wet
and furious at itself for being wet. "She said wait at the fountain till
afternoon. She said — " He stopped, breathed. "Mom always comes back as
promised."
The words landed in Michael like a hand on his sternum.
All at once he understood everything he hadn't let himself understand yet:
why a careful woman would leave an eight-year-old alone in a public square
with nothing but a paper bag. Because there had been no one else. Because
the tests couldn't wait, and the sitter cost money she didn't have, and the boy
was old enough — almost — and she had told herself the fountain was safe,
that afternoon would come, that mothers always come back as promised.
Saying it out loud to her son had been the only way to make herself believe
it.
And he understood, too, what it had cost Claire to walk away from that rim
this morning. He could see it with terrible clarity: her looking back once,
twice, memorizing the shape of him sitting there, carrying the picture of it
into whatever white room was waiting for her four blocks away.
Beside him, Lily was digging in her jacket pocket. She produced a granola
bar, slightly squashed, and held it out to Ethan with the gravity of a diplomat
presenting credentials.
"It's peanut butter," she said. "Dad says they're basically candy, but he's
45
wrong about snacks."
Ethan shook his head — small, automatic. Lily considered this, then set the
bar on the stone rim beside him anyway, within reach, without comment.
Michael watched his seven-year-old negotiate kindness the way other
children negotiated dessert, and felt something in his own chest crack open a
degree wider.
He thought of Claire at twenty-six, laughing at something he'd said across a
café table, sunlight in her hair — and then he thought of her this morning,
kneeling to button this boy's thin jacket, telling him to wait, telling him
mothers always come back as promised, and walking away down the street
with her hands in her pockets so he wouldn't see them shake. He had never
met that version of her. He owed her for it anyway.
"Nine years," Michael said quietly. Not to Ethan. To the arithmetic that had
been assembling itself in the back of his mind since he'd seen the
photograph.
Lily tugged his sleeve. "Dad?"
He stood. His knees cracked. Forty-one years old, partner at a law firm, eight
identical navy suits in a closet at home, and he had never in his life been less
certain of the correct procedure for anything.
He held out his hand to the boy.
Ethan looked at it. Then at Michael's face. The wariness came back up like a
tide, even through the tears.
"You're not even sure yet," Ethan said.
It wasn't an accusation. It was a fact, offered the way the boy offered
everything — carefully, as if words were things that could be taken away.
46
Michael didn't move his hand.
"No," he said. "I'm not sure."
The fountain hissed. A pigeon landed on the rim, reconsidered, left.
"But here's what I am sure of," Michael said. "You've been alone on this rim
since morning, doing exactly what she asked you to do, and you have waited
long enough. I don't know what the tests will say. I don't know the rest of it
yet. But right now the only thing that matters is getting to your mother. So
I'm going to walk you there."
He didn't move his hand.
Ethan looked at it — at the clean nails, at the pale band of skin where a
wedding ring had been until spring — and the fountain went on chattering
behind them, and Lily, for once in her seven years, said nothing at all.
47
Chapter 12
Four Blocks
Three seconds. Michael counted them by his own pulse.
Then Ethan's hand — small, cold, the knuckles reddened from the October
air — closed around two of Michael's fingers. Not the whole hand. A down
payment.
Lily, without being asked and without any ceremony at all, took Ethan's
other hand in hers, and the three of them stepped off the fountain's shadow
and onto the sidewalk like they'd been practicing it for years.
The streets were October at its most persuasive: leaves banked against the
curbs, the wind turning them over to show their pale undersides, shop
windows already lit though it was barely afternoon. They passed a bakery
exhaling cinnamon, a bus stop where an old man nodded at the children as if
they were a parade, a florist's buckets of chrysanthemums the color of egg
yolk.
"What's your favorite pancake state?" Lily demanded of Ethan, swinging
their joined hands a little.
Ethan glanced at her sideways. "I never had pancakes."
48
Lily stopped walking. Actually stopped, in the middle of the sidewalk, and
stared at him with the full force of seven-year-old moral outrage. "That's a
emergency," she declared. "Dad. Dad, that's a emergency."
"An emergency," Michael corrected automatically.
"That's what I said." She resumed walking, satisfied that the matter was now
officially on the record. "Florida's the best one because it's shaped like a
sock. But Texas is good too. It's shaped like — " She frowned. "Texas is
shaped like Texas."