Next part: A Little Boy Asked, “Are You My Dad?”—And One Photo Changed Everything

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

desk, about the eight navy suits and the functional life and the

nothing-quite-right of it. He thought about calling someone — whom? The

boy wasn't lost, exactly. He was waiting. His mother had told him to wait.

"Ethan." Michael kept his voice level. "How long have you been waiting?"

Ethan looked at him then, really looked, and Michael saw the calculation

again — how much to say, what it would cost. The boy glanced down at the

paper bag, then back up.

"Since morning," he said. Too casually. Like it was nothing. Like it was

everything.

11

Chapter 3

A Man in a Blue Suit

"Since morning" sat between them like a third person.

Michael had spent fourteen years as a lawyer learning to hear what people

didn't say. What Ethan wasn't saying filled the whole plaza. A mother who

leaves her eight-year-old at a fountain in October, in a jacket too thin for the

weather, with a paper bag for company — that was not an errand. That was

an arrangement.

He chose his words the way he'd choose them with a skittish witness. "Ethan,

is your mom okay?"

"She's sick." The boy said it flatly, staring at the water. "Not — not the kind

where you stay home. The kind where they keep you."

The hospital kind. Michael felt something cold move through him that had

nothing to do with the fountain mist.

"Is she — is she somewhere close?"

"She said four blocks." Ethan pointed vaguely east, past the maples. "That

way."

12

Michael didn't say the name out loud. St. Catherine's sat four blocks east, its

pale tower visible over the rooftops when the light was right — oncology,

mostly, and a cardiac wing. He'd done pro bono work for their foundation

two years back; he knew the visiting-hours policy, the particular smell of the

lobby, the way the elevators announced floors in a voice meant to be

soothing. He kept his face still. You didn't say hospital in front of a waiting

child. You didn't say it in front of your own seven-year-old either, who was

now watching him with those eyes — his eyes — gone suddenly serious.

"Okay," Michael said. "Okay." The mist settled on all three of them, beading

in Lily's hair like tiny glass.

Four blocks east of this park. Michael knew the neighborhood the way you

know a city you've lived in for twenty years without ever really seeing. Four

blocks east was St. Catherine's.

He didn't say it out loud. Lily was listening, swinging her legs again, and

some things you didn't say in front of seven-year-olds.

"Did she tell you when she'd be back?" Michael asked.

Ethan was quiet for a long moment. Then, slowly, he shifted the paper bag

on his lap. "She told me — if I was alone. If I was alone and I saw him."

"Saw who?"

"A man in a blue suit." Ethan's eyes flicked to Michael's trousers, to the navy

of his jacket where it showed beneath his overcoat. "She said there'd be a

man in a blue suit. And I was supposed to ask him one thing."

Michael looked down at himself. Navy suit, white shirt, the overcoat he'd

thrown on against the fountain chill. One of eight. He'd bought them all on

the same day three years ago, in a fit of decision-fatigue, and the salesman

13

had looked at him like he was unwell. Now the uniform felt like a signal

flare.

"Ethan," he said carefully, "do you know why your mom said a blue suit?

Did she say anything else about him?"

The boy's fingers worried at the bag's folded top. "She said — she'd know

him. The man. She said he was —" He searched for the word. "Good. She

said he was good, a long time ago, and good doesn't —" He frowned,

reciting. "Good doesn't wash off."

Lily whispered, "Like a tattoo?" and Ethan, despite everything, almost

smiled.

"Like that," he said. "Kind of."

Michael's mouth went dry. He was wearing one of the eight navy suits. He

wore one every day. It was the whole point of them — no decisions, no

thought, just the uniform of a functional life.

Lily had gone still beside him. Even she felt the temperature change.

"What were you supposed to ask him?" Michael heard himself say.

Ethan didn't answer right away. Instead he unfolded the top of the paper bag

— carefully, the way you'd open something that's been opened a thousand

times — and reached inside. His hand came out holding a photograph.

It was old. Michael could see that much even from the side: the paper

yellowed at the edges, the surface creased in a white cross where it had been

folded and unfolded, folded and unfolded, until the creases had become part

of the image. Ethan held it face-down against his palm. He didn't turn it over.

Not yet.

The creases were white with handling. Michael had seen evidence bags with

14

less wear. Whatever this photograph was, it had been carried — in the bag, in

a pocket, in a drawer — and taken out and looked at, over and over, for

years. You could read a whole life in the wear of an object if you knew how

to look, and Michael knew how to look. This was not a keepsake. This was a

compass.

"She said —" Ethan's voice caught, and he cleared his throat, annoyed at

himself the way kids get when their bodies betray them. "She said you'd

know her. The lady in the picture. She said if I found the man in the blue suit,

he'd know her."

The fountain roared softly behind them. A pigeon landed near Lily's shoe and

News in the same category

Next part: A Little Boy Asked, “Are You My Dad?”—And One Photo Changed Everything

20 Part