ambiguity to hide behind, and Claire had never been good at hiding anyway.
She sat on the edge of her mother's bathtub for a long time, listening to the
faucet drip, and thought about Michael Rourke in his fifth navy suit, kissing
her forehead on a train platform like a man closing a book.
She thought about calling him. She picked up the phone twice.
The first time, she got as far as his office number — she still knew it by
heart, the way you know songs from a summer — and a secretary with a
crisp voice said, "Mr. Rourke's in conference. May I tell him who's calling?"
And Claire heard herself say, "No. No, it's nothing," and hung up, because
it's nothing was suddenly, horribly true: to the woman answering that phone,
to the firm measuring him for partnership, to the whole gleaming apparatus
of his life, she was nothing. A summer. A conditional. A complication with a
due date.
36
The second time, she wrote a letter. She wrote it over three nights at her
mother's kitchen table, after her mother had gone to bed, and it was honest in
a way that frightened her — I'm pregnant, it's yours, I don't know what to do,
I thought you should know — and on the fourth morning she read it back
with daylight on it and saw what it really was: a complication, arriving by
mail, in the middle of the most important year of his life. He would do the
right thing. That was the problem, and she knew him well enough to know it.
Michael Rourke always did the right thing. She could already see the shape
of it — the dutiful visits scheduled between depositions, the checks, the slow
resentment curdling under the obligation, the two of them performing a
family the way he'd performed everything else until it hollowed out. And the
boy, growing up inside that performance, learning what love looked like
from two people acting.
She burned the letter in the kitchen sink and watched the words curl black.
She told herself it was pride. It was also fear, and it was also love — a
mother's love, arriving early — and she never sorted out the proportions. She
only knew she would not make her child into someone's duty.
When the baby came — a boy, eight pounds, her eyes and, unmistakably, his
jaw, the Rourke jaw like a signature — the nurse asked about the father's
surname for the birth certificate. Claire could have written her own name.
She'd gone back to it in every way that counted. Instead she wrote Rourke, in
her clear teacher's hand, the hand that had graded a thousand spelling tests,
and when the nurse raised an eyebrow she said, "So he'll have his father's
name." It was the one true thing she could give the boy without asking
anyone's permission, and she gave it freely.
She raised Ethan on a teacher's salary and her mother's help and a
stubbornness she hadn't known she owned. There were thin jackets and
37
repaired shoes and a worn paper bag for his lunches, because the good
backpacks cost what groceries cost. There were bedtime stories and help with
long division and the particular exhaustion of being the only adult in a small
house. She told him his father was a good man who lived far away and loved
him the way distant stars love the earth — present, just not close. It wasn't a
lie so much as a translation, the way she'd once translated poetry for a man in
a bookstore.
When Ethan was six, he asked the question she'd been rehearsing for since
before he was born. They were on the porch, her mother's house, fireflies out
early. "Why doesn't my dad live with us?" he said, swinging his legs, not
looking at her. "Tommy's dad lives with Tommy."
Claire's heart did something complicated behind her ribs. "Do you remember
the stars I showed you?" she said. "How the light takes years to get here, but
it's still real light?" He nodded, suspicious. "It's like that," she said. "He's far
away, but the love still gets here." Ethan considered this with a six-year-old's
judicial gravity. "That's a weird way to be a dad," he announced. "Yes,"
Claire said, and pulled him against her side, and hoped he couldn't feel how
hard her heart was beating. "It is. I'm sorry, baby."
The tiredness started when Ethan was six. She told herself it was the job, the
years, the single parenting — the usual suspects, all guilty. By the time she
admitted it might be something else, the something else had gotten a head
start. The doctor at St. Catherine's — four blocks from the fountain where
she used to walk on her lunch breaks, back when she lived in the city, back
when everything was conditional — looked at her chart with the expression
doctors wear when the news needs a room of its own.
"We need to run more tests," he said. "Today, if we can manage it."
38
She nodded, and thought of the fountain, and of a man in a blue suit who
walked past it every Wednesday afternoon on his way home from the firm —
because some habits, she'd learned from the best, never change. Eight
identical navy suits now, she'd heard, from a friend of a friend. The
interrogation joke came back to her, and she almost smiled, and then she
didn't.
That evening she gave Ethan the creased photograph, and the instructions —
Wednesday, the fountain, a man in a blue suit, ask him one thing — and she
told him exactly what to say, and she held him a little longer than usual at
bedtime, memorizing the weight of him.
39
Chapter 10
What He Never Knew
The fountain kept doing what fountains do — throwing water at the October
sky, indifferent to the small earthquake happening beside it.
Michael stood with the creased photograph in his hand and felt nine years
collapse like a telescope. He'd been counting wrong. All this time he'd told
himself the Claire chapter was a summer, four months, a closed book — and
it had been a whole life running parallel to his, eight years long, in a town
two hours north, in classrooms and kitchens he'd never seen. First steps
across a linoleum floor. First words. A boy learning to read with her teacher's