Next part: A Little Boy Asked, “Are You My Dad?”—And One Photo Changed Everything

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"And Lily?"

"Has already decided he's her brother. She informed me of this. There was no

vote."

A sound that might have been a laugh, or might have been its tired cousin.

"Of course she did." Another pause, longer this time. He could hear her

moving around her kitchen — the clink of a mug, the kettle being lifted.

"Michael. Are you sure? About the — the paternity?"

"I haven't done the test yet. I'll do it this week, for the paperwork. But — "

He looked down the hallway, toward the two closed doors. "Yes. I'm sure."

"Tell me about her," his ex-wife said. "The mother."

So he told her about Claire — the summer nine years ago, the choice she'd

made to raise Ethan alone and never tell him, the Rourke surname she'd kept

like a promise she wasn't sure anyone would collect. He told her about St.

Catherine's, the treatable diagnosis, the surgery, the months of recovery

ahead. He did not dress any of it up. She had always been able to tell when

he was lawyering her.

"She's brave," his ex-wife said quietly. "To do it alone." A beat. "Michael, I

need to ask you something, and I need the real answer, not the

closing-argument one."

"Okay."

"Are you doing this because you feel guilty? Because if it's guilt, it'll curdle."

The question landed cleanly, the way her best questions always had. Michael

70

looked out the kitchen window at the fire escape, at the pigeons already

gathering.

"No," he said. "Guilt was the first hour. He stood in my apartment last night

holding a paper bag with his whole life in it, and he asked if he could keep

the bag. And I understood that the bravest thing anyone's done in my

presence in years was an eight-year-old walking up to a stranger and asking,

'Are you my dad?' I'm not doing this from guilt. I'm doing it because he's my

son, and he's here, and the door's open."

She exhaled, slowly. "Good. That's good." He heard her set the mug down.

"What does Lily need from me in all this?"

"Just normal," Michael said. "She'll tell you everything herself. Maybe ask

her about the card game."

"I'll ask about the card game," she said. "And Michael — bring them both

Sunday. I'll make pancakes. The good ones, with the blueberries."

"Because of the eyes."

"Because of the eyes. And because of — " He stopped. "Because he asked

me. He walked up to a stranger in a plaza and asked, 'Are you my dad?' You

don't ask that unless something in you already knows the answer."

She was quiet for a moment. Then: "What's his name?"

"Ethan."

"Ethan," she repeated, trying it out. "Okay. Here's what I need to know, and I

need you to be honest. Is this going to hurt Lily?"

Michael closed his eyes. This was the question he had asked himself all

night, turning it over like a stone. "I think it's going to change her," he said.

"I think she's going to have to share things — me, the apartment, the last

71

pancake. I think there will be fights. But hurt her?" He thought of Lily on the

couch, patting the cushion, treating a box of nub crayons like treasure. "No. I

think it's going to make her bigger."

"Good answer." He could hear her pouring the kettle now. "Bring them both

Sunday. I'll make pancakes. The good ones, with the blueberries. And

Michael — "

"Yes?"

"You're doing the right thing. Don't let anyone, including me on a bad day,

tell you different."

He thanked her, and meant it, and hung up feeling like he'd just passed

something he hadn't studied for.

Lily was standing in the kitchen doorway in her pajamas, one sock on, hair in

a haystack.

"How much did you hear?" he asked.

"The pancake part," she said. "And the part where you said I'm going to be

bigger." She considered this. "I am already the tallest in my reading group."

"That's not what I meant."

"I know." She climbed onto a stool. "Is she mad?"

"No. She's — she's being very decent about it."

Lily nodded, satisfied, as if decency were the minimum she'd expected and

was pleased to have it confirmed. "Tell Ethan the pancakes have blueberries.

He'll want to know. He likes knowing things in advance. I can tell."

"I'll tell him."

72

She poured herself a glass of orange juice with the concentration of a

chemist, then looked up. "Dad? Are you scared?"

The question caught him off guard. "A little," he admitted. "Are you?"

"A little," she said. "But it's the good kind. Like before a recital." She took a

sip. "Ethan's scared too, but his is the bad kind. The kind where you don't

know if there's going to be dinner. So we have to make sure he knows. About

dinner, I mean. And everything else."

Michael looked at his seven-year-old daughter, standing in his kitchen in one

sock, and felt the ground shift under him in the way it had been shifting all

week — the organized life giving way to something messier and more alive.

"We will," he said. "Every day, until he stops needing to be told. And then

we'll keep telling him anyway."

73

Chapter 18

Paperwork

Michael had always believed there were two kinds of love: the kind you felt,

News in the same category

Next part: A Little Boy Asked, “Are You My Dad?”—And One Photo Changed Everything

20 Part