Lily, without a word, slid off the fountain's edge and wrapped her arms
around Ethan's shoulders. He stiffened — then didn't. Michael watched his
daughter hold this boy, his son, and felt the color-coded calendar, the eight
navy suits, the functional life, all of it go very quiet and very far away.
He stood. The photograph was still in his hand. He folded it — gently, along
the white creases — and slipped it into his breast pocket, over his heart,
where it belonged.
"Okay," Michael said. "Okay, Ethan. Here's what's going to happen."
Both children looked up at him.
"We're going to go see your mom."
23
Chapter 6
Nine Years Ago
At thirty-two, Michael Rourke owned four identical navy suits and believed,
with the fervor of the recently converted, that a life could be organized into
submission. He woke at five-forty without an alarm. He ran three miles along
the river in all weather. He kept his briefs in labeled folders, his hours in
six-minute increments, his kitchen counters clear enough to perform surgery
on. He was a third-year associate at Hartwell & Crane, which meant he billed
sixty hours a week and slept in whatever was left over, and he told himself
this was temporary, the way people in burning buildings tell themselves the
smoke is temporary.
That Saturday in June he had a deposition to prepare for Monday, a birthday
gift to buy for his mother, and no idea what to get her. His mother was the
kind of woman who read everything and forgave nothing, and the year before
he had bought her a scarf and she had worn it exactly once, to teach him
something. He stood in his bedroom that morning and looked at the four
navy suits hanging in a row like jurors, and chose the second one, because
the first was for Mondays.
The deposition prep took four hours. His mother took forty-five minutes of
24
agonizing in a department store, where everything looked like a surrender. It
was past two when he ducked into a used bookstore on Halsted Street to get
out of the heat, telling himself he'd browse for five minutes.
The store smelled of paper and dust and the particular melancholy of other
people's discarded lives. He drifted to the biography section and picked up a
life of Eleanor Roosevelt and stood there holding it, feeling like a fraud,
because he knew his mother would see through it in a paragraph.
"You look like a man buying a book he has no intention of reading," said a
voice behind him.
She was shelving paperbacks, a stack balanced against her hip, dark hair
coming loose from where she'd pinned it. She had the kind of direct gaze that
made Michael want to straighten his tie, and he wasn't wearing a tie. Her
name tag said CLAIRE, in handwriting that leaned left.
"It's for my mother," he said, which was true and also a complete surrender.
"Does your mother read Eleanor Roosevelt?"
"My mother reads whatever I bring her, and then she tells me what she thinks
of my judgment."
She laughed — a real laugh, sudden and unguarded, the kind of sound people
in his office had trained themselves out of years ago. It did something to the
dust in the air. "Then buy her the good one." She plucked a different
biography off the shelf without looking, the way a pianist finds keys. "This
one doesn't flinch. Mothers respect that."
He bought it. He also bought, at her recommendation, a novel he'd never
heard of, because she described it in three sentences — a lighthouse, a lie, a
woman who keeps both — and he wanted to keep listening to her describe
25
things. When he asked if she worked there full time, she said, "Saturdays. I
teach during the week. Fourth grade. They grade me harder than your
partners grade you."
"That's impossible," he said.
"Come observe one Tuesday," she said. "Bring your six-minute increments.
The children will eat them alive."
He went back the next Saturday. He told himself it was for another book. He
bought poetry he didn't understand and asked her to explain it, and she did —
patiently, the way you'd explain a joke to someone you liked too much to
mock. She asked what he did, and when he said "corporate litigation," she
said, "That sounds like a weather pattern," and he laughed so hard the owner
looked over from the register.
The store was closing. He should have left — the deposition outline was
waiting, his Sunday run, his labeled folders. Instead he heard himself say,
"Can I buy you a coffee," and she said, "Only if you let me order something
with too much foam," and they walked two blocks to a café with mismatched
chairs, and he stayed for two hours.
She told him about her fourth graders. There was a boy named Marcus who
read three grades ahead and hid it because the other boys teased him, and a
girl named Priya who corrected Claire's spelling on the board, kindly, the
way you'd tell a friend they had spinach in their teeth. She talked about them
the way Michael's partners talked about precedent — with total authority and
visible love — and he found himself telling her about the deposition, about
the witness who'd lied in a way that was almost elegant, and she listened like
it mattered, asking the exact right question twice.
Walking home, the June evening warm on his face, he realized he couldn't
26
remember the last time he'd talked to someone who wasn't measuring him.
Everyone in his life wanted something: hours, results, a version of him that
fit their plans. Claire had wanted a coffee with too much foam and his honest
opinion of a poem. It felt like being let out of a room he'd forgotten he was
locked in.
She asked him questions nobody in his life asked. Not "what are you