Racist Cop Slams a Black Girl Against His Patrol Car — Then Discovers Her Mother Is a Federal Prosecutor

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The attention was not kind in the way that attention is often unkind. Reporters called the house. Neighbors knocked on the door with casseroles and with questions. People Simone had not spoken to in years sent messages offering help and offering opinions, sometimes in the same sentence. Aaliyah, who had been a private child, suddenly found herself known to strangers, and she did not like it. She told her mother that she was tired of explaining, and Simone understood, because she was tired of explaining too, and they were both grateful for the help and exhausted by the attention that came with it, and both feelings could be true at once. Simone told Aaliyah that she did not have to explain anything to anyone except the investigators, and the doctors, and her teachers, and that she could say, politely and firmly, that she would rather not talk about it, and that most decent people would respect that. Most did. Some did not, and Simone learned to be grateful for the most and patient with the some.

Aaliyah returned to school the following Monday, because Simone believed that routine was a form of care, and because Aaliyah herself had asked to go, even though she was nervous. Her teacher, a woman named Mrs. Alvarez, met her at the door of the classroom with a quiet word and a seat near the window, and she told the class, without naming Aaliyah, that they would be kind to one another and that they would not ask questions that were not theirs to ask. The children were mostly kind. A few asked questions anyway, because children are curious and because they had seen the video too, or heard about it from older brothers and sisters, and Aaliyah answered the ones she could answer and declined the ones she could not, with a steadiness that surprised even Simone. At lunch, a girl she barely knew sat beside her and said, without preamble, that she was sorry, and Aaliyah said thank you, and they ate in silence for a while, and it was, in its small way, enough.

Simone recused herself formally that week, in a short written statement filed with her office and shared, at her request, with the press. It was not long. It said that her daughter had been involved in an incident with a Westbridge police officer, that she had filed a formal complaint, that she would have no role in any case touching the Westbridge police, and that she was speaking as a mother, not as a prosecutor, because this was about a child, not about her office. She did not name Mallerie in the statement. She did not describe the video. She did not ask for sympathy. She asked only that the process be allowed to work, and that her daughter be allowed to be a child again. The statement was quoted widely, and Simone was glad that it was short, because short statements are harder to misquote, and because she had said everything she needed to say.

Mallerie was placed on administrative leave the same week, a decision announced in a single paragraph by the chief's office, without elaboration, and his union issued a statement of its own, defending him, questioning the video, suggesting that the full context had not been shown, and warning against a rush to judgment. Simone read the union's statement carefully, as she read everything, and she noted what it did not say: it did not say that Aaliyah had crossed against the light, because she had not; it did not say that she had resisted, because the video showed that she had not; it did not say that the camera had been on, because it had not. It spoke in generalities, and generalities, Simone knew, were what people used when the specifics were against them.

Mallerie's family reacted in the way families react when a private failure becomes public. His wife, who had not been at the intersection and had not seen the video until a neighbor showed it to her, called Simone's office and left a message asking, in a voice that was angry and frightened at once, whether Simone understood what this would do to their children. Simone returned the call herself, that evening, and spoke to the woman for ten minutes, calmly, without raising her voice, and said that she did understand, and that she was sorry for what the family was going through, and that she would not speak about Mallerie's children in public, and that she hoped the woman would understand that Aaliyah was also a child. The woman cried, very quietly, and thanked her, and hung up. Simone sat for a long time after that call, thinking about how many children there were in the story now, and how none of them had chosen any of it.

News in the same category

Racist Cop Slams a Black Girl Against His Patrol Car — Then Discovers Her Mother Is a Federal Prosecutor

45 Part