Racist Cop Slams a Black Girl Against His Patrol Car — Then Discovers Her Mother Is a Federal Prosecutor

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The outside review, which had been ordered after the hearing, began its work that week. It was not led by anyone from Westbridge. The reviewers came from outside the county, and they brought with them the patience of people who were used to reading files that other people had hoped would stay closed. They asked for every pedestrian-stop complaint filed against Mallerie over the previous six years. They asked for the notes, the dispositions, the names of the supervisors who had signed them. They asked for the radio logs from the afternoon of July eighteenth, and for the body camera records, and for the training records that showed what Mallerie had been taught about stops involving children, and when he had last been taught it.

What they found was not a single missing page. It was a shape. Twenty-three pedestrian-stop complaints over six years. Most of them had never been investigated in any meaningful sense. Some had been marked unfounded after a single conversation with the officer involved. Some had been filed and then filed away, the complainants never contacted again. A few had been withdrawn, and the reviewers, reading the notes carefully, could see why: the people who had filed them had been told, politely and firmly, that pursuing the matter would take time, that it would require statements, that it might bring attention to their families. The language was never threatening. It did not need to be. It only needed to be discouraging enough.

Simone did not learn these numbers from a headline. She learned them from a briefing, delivered in a plain room with a plain table, by a woman who spoke in the same measured tone Simone used in court. The woman laid out the figures without emphasis, letting the numbers speak for themselves, and Simone listened the way she had taught herself to listen over twenty years of practice: without interrupting, without deciding in advance what the numbers meant, without letting her own feelings do the work that the evidence was supposed to do. When the briefing ended, she asked only one question. She asked whether the two supervisors who had signed off on the buried complaints had been told what the review had found. The woman said yes, they had been told, and that they had been reassigned pending further review, removed from any role in which they would decide whether a complaint against an officer was worth investigating.

Simone wrote the number down in her notebook, not because she needed to remember it, but because writing it down made it real in a way that hearing it had not. Twenty-three. She thought about each of those twenty-three people, most of whom she would never meet, and about what it meant to have spoken up and then to have been met with silence. She thought about Aaliyah, twelve years old, ninety-three pounds, a white paper pharmacy bag in her hand, and about how easily that afternoon could have become complaint number twenty-four, filed and forgotten, if a teenager on a bicycle had not pulled out his phone.

Marcus was seventeen, and he had not set out to become a witness. He had been riding home, he had seen a child being pressed against a patrol car, and he had done the only thing that seemed both safe and useful: he had filmed, from a distance, without shouting, without stepping closer than he needed to, holding the phone steady. The footage he had taken was forty seconds long at first, then longer, as he kept recording while the officer called for everyone to stay back. He had not known, when he pressed record, that the video would be watched by thousands of people, or that it would be shown in a hearing room, or that a federal inquiry would one day ask him to describe, in his own words, what he had seen. He had only known that something was wrong, and that a record of it might matter.

In the weeks after the hearing, Marcus was thanked by the city, in a ceremony that was brief and formal and, to his surprise, not at all about him. The mayor spoke for three minutes. A council member spoke for two. Marcus spoke for less than one, and what he said was simple. He said he had filmed because he did not want to forget what he had seen, and because he did not want anyone else to have to take his word for it. He said he had been scared, and that being scared had not stopped him from holding the phone steady. He said he hoped other teenagers would know that they could do the same, safely, and that they did not need to be brave in a loud way to be useful.

After the ceremony, a teacher from his school asked him if he would help start a youth media program, and Marcus said yes before he had time to think about whether he was ready. The program met twice a week in a classroom with old computers and a whiteboard that squeaked. The teenagers who came were not there because they wanted to be famous. They were there because they had seen things in their neighbourhoods — a stop that went too far, a door knocked on too hard, a friend treated as if he were older and more dangerous than he was — and they wanted to know how to record what happened without putting themselves in danger, and how to tell the story of what they had recorded without exaggerating it, without leaving out the parts that did not fit the version they wished were true.

News in the same category

Racist Cop Slams a Black Girl Against His Patrol Car — Then Discovers Her Mother Is a Federal Prosecutor

45 Part