Racist Cop Slams a Black Girl Against His Patrol Car — Then Discovers Her Mother Is a Federal Prosecutor

Chapter 35

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The letter arrived on a Tuesday, in an ordinary white envelope with a return address in a part of the city Simone did not know well, and a stamp that had been placed a little crookedly, as if the person who sent it had hesitated over the smallest part of the task. Simone found it in the mailbox after work, between a flyer for a roofing company and a notice from the water department, and she knew, before she opened it, that it was not a bill or an advertisement. She carried it into the kitchen, set it on the counter beside the chipped blue mug, and looked at it for a long moment while the refrigerator hummed and the late afternoon light came through the window in a slant that made the dust visible in the air. She did not open it immediately. She washed her hands, she poured a glass of water, she sat down at the table, and only then did she slide a finger under the flap and unfold the single sheet of paper inside. The handwriting was careful, the letters formed slowly, as if the writer had been afraid of making a mistake that would make the whole thing unreadable, and the first line gave her the name she had expected and had not expected at the same time. Trent Mallerie.

He was working in a warehouse now, the letter said, on a night shift that left him tired in a way that policing had not, and he had written the letter three times before sending it, because the first two versions had sounded, in his own reading, like excuses. He did not ask for forgiveness. He did not ask for a job, or a recommendation, or a meeting, or a reply. He wrote that he had been convicted, that he was banned from law enforcement, that he understood the ban was permanent and that it should be, and that he had spent the year since the trial learning to see the afternoon at Laurel and North Mercer as Aaliyah must have seen it, rather than as he had told himself to see it at the time. He named the things he had not named in court, or had named only when a lawyer prompted him. The heat. The metal of the patrol car, baking beneath the July sun for hours. The thin cotton of a yellow t-shirt. The pharmacy bag, white paper with a green logo, folded beneath his palm. The bottle of allergy tablets knocking against a second bottle containing a prescription for her mother. The child he should have seen, twelve years old, ninety-three pounds, with one braid fallen across her face, saying please, saying she was not resisting, saying she had the light. He wrote that he had heard himself say stop resisting, and that he had known, even then, that she was not resisting, and that he had said it anyway because the words gave him a reason to keep holding on. He wrote that he had pressed his forearm across her upper back, that he had called it a lawful pedestrian stop, that he had told the bystanders to stay back, and that he had believed, in the moment, that his uniform made those words true. He wrote that he understood now that it did not.

Simone read the letter twice, slowly, and then she read it a third time, not because she had missed anything, but because she wanted to be certain about what it was and what it was not. It was not a legal document. It was not a request for leniency. It was not, as far as she could tell, a performance for anyone else, because there was no one else named in it, no lawyer copied, no organization thanked, no audience addressed beyond the two people at the address on the envelope. It was a letter from a man who had lost the work that had defined him, who was working nights in a warehouse, and who had decided, for reasons Simone could not fully know and did not need to fully know, to write down what he had done in plain language. She thought about the training sessions at the academy, about the officers who sat in the front row and the officers who sat in the back, about the rule on the whiteboard and the way a reason spoken aloud could be examined. She thought about the difference between an apology that asked for something and an apology that simply owned something, and she thought that this letter, for all its careful handwriting and its crooked stamp, belonged to the second kind. That did not make it sufficient. It did not make it welcome. It made it a thing that had been received, and therefore a thing that had to be answered, or not answered, with the same care with which it had been written.

She did not tell Aaliyah about the letter that evening. She folded it, put it back in its envelope, and set the envelope in the drawer where she kept the household papers, beside the receipt for the refrigerator repair and the school forms she had not yet signed. She made dinner, she asked Aaliyah about the debate team's next resolution, she listened to her daughter talk about a classmate who had argued passionately for a position she did not believe in, just to test whether she could. She washed the dishes, she dried the chipped blue mug and put it back on the shelf, she checked the locks on the doors, and she went to bed with the letter still in the drawer, unanswered, and with the knowledge that she would have to decide, in her own time, what to do with it. She had spent a year telling other people that accuracy could be its own kind of steadiness, and now she had to practice that steadiness in her own kitchen, without a courtroom, without a whiteboard, without an audience. She had to decide what was certain and what was only suspected, and she had to separate the two, even when the separation was slow and unsatisfying.

News in the same category

Racist Cop Slams a Black Girl Against His Patrol Car — Then Discovers Her Mother Is a Federal Prosecutor

45 Part