I was there for the verdict. We all were, Marco and Elena and Sarah Kim and me, sitting in the back row in our ordinary clothes, holding our breath. The jury filed in. The foreman stood. The judge asked for the verdict on the first count, attempted murder, and the foreman said guilty. The second count, conspiracy, guilty. The third count, the murder of Antonio Romano, guilty. I did not feel triumph. I felt a long, slow exhale, like a breath I had been holding for a year had finally left my body. Vitale did not react. He sat very still, his hands folded on the table, and looked at the floor. The judge thanked the jury and set a date for sentencing. Outside, on the courthouse steps, reporters shouted questions, and Sarah Kim put a hand on my shoulder and steered me past them, and Marco opened the car door, and I sat down and closed my eyes and thought about Antonio, a man I had never met, a detective who had refused a bribe and died for it, and I thought about my mother, who had taught me to do the right thing even when it cost me, and I thought that maybe, just maybe, the world was not entirely unfair.
Vitale was sentenced to life in prison, without the possibility of parole, a month later, on a cold morning in November when the wind came off the harbour and rattled the windows of the courtroom. The judge spoke for a long time, in that same low, tired voice, about the poison and the badge and the envelope and Antonio, and about the way Vitale had used other people as tools and then thrown them away, and about the way justice, when it finally came, was slow but certain. Vitale stood to hear his sentence, and he did not speak, and he did not look at Dominic, and he did not look at me. He looked at the judge, and then he looked at the floor, and then two officers led him away. I watched him go, and I felt nothing at all, which surprised me, because I had expected to feel anger or relief or joy, and instead I felt empty, like a room after the furniture has been taken out. Sarah Kim squeezed my hand and said, it is over, Chloe, at least this part is over, and I nodded, because she was right, but I also knew that there were two more trials to go, and that being a witness was not a single day's work but a season of my life, and I would have to walk into those courtrooms too, and tell the same story again, and be exact again, and not cry again, and I was tired already just thinking about it. But I went. I went because Antonio deserved it, and because Dominic deserved it, and because Clara, the woman I had been a year ago, the waitress who had knelt beside a dying man at table four and called for help, deserved to see it through to the end.
Vincent Cross's trial came next, in the same courthouse, in a smaller room with worse lighting and a jury that looked younger and more nervous. Cross was a different kind of defendant than Vitale. He was not old and tired. He was in his forties, tall and broad-shouldered, with the kind of face that had once been handsome and was now hard, and he wore his suit like a uniform, as if he were still a detective and the courtroom were still his beat. He had been a detective once, a real one, before Vitale bought him, and that was what made his crime worse in the eyes of the jury, I think, because he had taken an oath and broken it for money. He had been the hitman, the man with the badge, the man who had poisoned Dominic's coffee and then tried to make it look like an accident, and when Dominic had shown Vitale the badge, Vitale had frozen, because he had recognised it as his own man's badge, and that moment, that freeze, had been the beginning of the end for all of them. Cross's lawyer tried a different tactic than Vitale's lawyer had. He did not try to make me look confused. He tried to make me look small. He asked me about the restaurant, about my wages, about my mother's bills, about the fact that I had no degree and no savings and no family left, as if poverty were a kind of dishonesty. He asked me if Dominic had promised me a better life in exchange for my testimony. I said no, that Dominic had offered me money seventeen times and I had refused it seventeen times, and that the only promise anyone had made me was Sarah Kim's promise that if I told the truth, the truth would protect me. He asked me if I had ever been in trouble with the police. I said no. He asked me if I had ever lied to get a job. I said no. He asked me if I was sure it was Cross who had poisoned the coffee, since I had not seen him do it. I said I had not seen him poison the coffee, and I would not pretend that I had, but I had seen Dominic collapse, and I had seen the badge, and I had seen Vitale freeze, and I had heard Dominic tell me, in the hospital, who Cross was and what he had done, and I believed him, because Dominic had no reason to lie to me about the man who had tried to kill him. The lawyer sat down, looking frustrated, and I felt a small, quiet pride, because I had not exaggerated, and I had not guessed, and I had not let him push me into saying more than I knew. Being exact was my protection. Being exact was my power.