She Fell From the Rooftop at Her Own Party — and the Maid Let the World Believe She Was Gone

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

What happened on the roof in the next ten minutes had the quality of a building deciding to fall: noise everywhere, structure nowhere. The fireworks, indifferent, continued their program over the river while below them two hundred guests surged toward the east corner and were beaten back by Marcus Webb and his men with a competence that looked, in retrospect, like the only competent thing that happened all night. Someone was screaming in a continuous, tearing voice that turned out to be a senator's wife. The quartet's cellist stood holding his bow like a man at a funeral. Nate ran — Rosa would remember that too, the heir of the Hartwells running like a schoolboy, shoving past a mayor, arriving at the railing white-faced and already saying her name — and leaned so far over the rail after his mother that Webb had to take him around the waist and haul him back bodily.

"She climbed up on the ledge," Vanessa was saying, to everyone, to no one, her hands pressed to her face and her voice shaking with a hysteria that had, Rosa thought, the strangest quality of being at once entirely false and entirely real. "She wanted the photograph with the whole city — she said the railing was too low, she got up on the little ledge to be above the skyline, I begged her, I said, Evelyn, please, and she laughed at me, she laughed, and then she just — she went — she was there and then the sky—" She collapsed with great completeness into the arms of a congresswoman, and her father, arriving at a run, gathered her up and held her and looked over her head at the corner with the eyes of a man watching his own house burn.

The police came up in waves: first the hotel's detail, then uniformed officers filling the garden, then the quiet, tired professionals who parted the guests the way weather parts a crowd. Detective Dana Ruiz of the NYPD arrived at eleven-forty with her notebook already in her hand and took one long look at the east corner, at the low decorative railing, at the ledge of stone eight inches wide that ran along its base, and at Vanessa, before she said anything at all. She was forty-four, plain-faced, with the patience of a woman who has learned that scenes settle if you let them, and she let this one settle while the searchlights came on below and the first reports began to come up from the street.

For that was the thing — the thing that moved, in the space of an hour, from being a detail to being the entire shape of the night. Evelyn Hart had gone over a railing thirty-one floors above Fifth Avenue, and there was no Evelyn Hart on Fifth Avenue. The street had been closed; guests' cars had been moved; officers with lights had walked the avenue, the side streets, the marquees and canopies and ledges of the Hartwell's own face and of every face across the way. There was broken glass on the roof from a dropped tray, noted and photographed. There was a scarf, silk, champagne-colored, caught on a vent housing two floors down, identified by Nate in a voice that did not sound like his as a gift his fiancée had given his mother that afternoon. There was no body. There was no blood. There was, as one young officer put it to Ruiz in an undertone Rosa was not meant to hear, nothing at all, ma'am, like she fell into the sky.

"People do not fall into the sky," Ruiz said, without looking up from her notebook. "They land somewhere we haven't looked, or they didn't fall the way we were told. Keep looking."

They kept looking until nearly three in the morning — setbacks, rooftops of the lower neighbors, the hotel's own mechanical floors, the river of traffic footage from the avenue's cameras, in which a white shape, possibly a banner, possibly nothing, blurred across one frame at the relevant minute and resolved into nothing anyone could swear to. And all the while, in the salon below, Vanessa gave her account again for the record, and again, with her father's hand locked on her shoulder and Nate destroyed beside her in a chair he seemed to have fallen into rather than chosen — Nate, who kept saying, at intervals, to no one, "She would never climb on a ledge. She was afraid of nothing but she wasn't — she would never. Not in heels. Not for a photograph. She hated being photographed; she said it was for monuments and criminals," and who wept, openly and without shame, into his hands, a thirty-five-year-old man orphaned between one firework and the next in a room full of flowers. Vanessa, weeping too, reached for his hand throughout her statement, and held it, and answered every question with a completeness that Ruiz's notebook recorded without comment.

"She'd had champagne," Vanessa said. "Two glasses, three. She was — gay, tonight, she was celebrating, she said seventy was nothing, she said the city was hers and she wanted to stand above it. I told her the ledge was madness. Detective, I swear to you, I begged her. And when she went I — I couldn't reach her. I was too far. I was arranging the photograph. I shall hear that sound — no. There was no sound. That's the worst of it. There was no sound at all."

News in the same category

She Fell From the Rooftop at Her Own Party — and the Maid Let the World Believe She Was Gone

45 Part