The café Darius chose was not the one where they had first met, and not the one near the house where Evelyn Carter was watching Kayla Mitchell that morning, building a tower out of wooden blocks and knocking it down again just to hear the sound it made. It was a quiet place on a side street in Midtown, with plain wooden tables and a window that looked out onto a row of trees still holding their early leaves, and he arrived twenty minutes early so that he could choose the table in the corner, the one furthest from the door, where no one would have to raise their voice to be heard and no one would be listening in. He ordered a coffee he did not really want and set the manila envelope down on the table beside it, not hidden, not displayed, just there, flat and ordinary, the way a bill or a letter might sit. He had spent the night before reading the papers inside it again, slowly, twice, not because he did not already know what they said but because he wanted to be sure that when he spoke he would be speaking about what was true and not about what he had imagined in the long hours after Evelyn had found it in the dressing-room drawer. The adoption papers were folded neatly, the hospital report clipped behind them, the unsent letter in Brittany's own handwriting tucked at the back, its ink a little faded at the edges, its sentences stopping and starting as if she had written it in pieces over a long time and never found a way to finish it. He would lay out what he knew, plainly, and then he would ask her to tell the truth in her own words, because Kayla deserved that much, and because Brittany, for all the harm she had done, was still a person who had once been nineteen and frightened and alone, and he wanted to hear how she understood it now, when she was no longer nineteen and no longer able to pretend that the past had stayed in Savannah.
Brittany arrived five minutes late, her hair pulled back, her coat buttoned to the top, her eyes moving quickly around the room before they settled on him, and for a moment she looked like a woman walking into a job interview she did not want, careful and guarded and already braced for bad news. She sat down across from him and folded her hands on the table, and he saw that her nails were bitten short, a habit he had not noticed before, or had noticed and not thought about, back when they were planning a wedding and she was choosing flowers and tasting cakes and talking about the future as if it were something you could order in advance. "Thank you for coming," he said, and his voice sounded calm to his own ears, steadier than he felt, and she nodded once, sharply, as if she were accepting a formality rather than a kindness. "I asked you here because there are things we need to talk about, and I wanted to do it somewhere quiet, just the two of us, without Kayla hearing any of it, without Evelyn having to stand between us." He slid the envelope across the table, not pushing it, just moving it the few inches that put it between them, and he watched her face change as she recognised it, the colour leaving her cheeks first and then coming back in a rush, her hands tightening around each other until the knuckles went white. "I found this," he said. "In the dressing room. In the drawer. Evelyn found it first, and she brought it to me, because she thought I needed to know. I have read everything in it. I have read the adoption papers, and the hospital report, and the letter you never sent. I know about Hope."
The name hung in the air between them, small and ordinary and impossible to take back once it had been said out loud in that quiet café, and Brittany stared at the envelope as if it might open on its own and say the rest for her. For a long moment she said nothing at all, and then she laughed, a short, sharp sound that was not amusement, and shook her head. "You went through my things," she said, and her voice was tight, defensive, the voice of someone who has been caught and is reaching for the nearest reason to be angry instead. "That drawer was mine. That was private. You had no right to go through my private things." Darius did not rise to it. He kept his hands flat on the table, his coffee untouched, his eyes on hers, and he waited until the silence had done its work. "Evelyn found it while she was cleaning," he said, evenly. "She did not go looking for