"Don't listen to her," Celeste said. She had come up behind Adrian and put a hand on his back, and her voice was urgent now, close, intimate, the voice of a wife talking to her husband about a servant. "She's lying, Adrian. She's lying to save her job. You know what she's like. You know what happened with the bracelet. She lies, and then she cries, and then everyone feels sorry for her. She let go of the handle and our baby went down the stairs, and if you let her talk, she'll talk her way out of it, the way she always does."
The bracelet. Three weeks ago. The gold bracelet Celeste had accused her of taking, found two days later in Celeste's own jewellery drawer, where Celeste herself had left it. No apology had followed. And now here it was again, brought into the room like evidence, like proof of a character.
Molly felt something in her chest go very still and very cold.
"Adrian," she said again, and she made her voice as quiet and as plain as she could, because quiet and plain were the only things she had left. "I never let go of her. Not once. Ask Sadie. Sadie was on the landing. She saw."
Adrian's grip on her arm did not loosen. He was breathing hard. He looked from Molly's face to his wife's face and back again, and Molly could see him doing the arithmetic that men in his position always do, the terrible, familiar arithmetic: the wife who is crying, the employee who is calm, and which of them is telling the truth, and how much it will cost to believe the wrong one.
"Let go of my arm," Molly said. "Please. I need both arms for Ivy. She's shaking."
For a moment she thought he would not. His fingers were white around her sleeve. Then, slowly, he let go, and Molly stepped back, and gathered Ivy into both arms, and pressed her cheek to the top of the baby's head, and breathed in the smell of her hair, which was clean and warm and ordinary, and which meant, more than anything else in the room, that the baby was alive and unhurt.
"She needs to be checked," Molly said. "By a doctor. Not because I think she's hurt — I stopped the stroller before it could turn over — but because she went down the stairs and she should be checked. That's the only thing that matters right now."
"She's trying to change the subject," Celeste said. "Adrian, she's trying to make it about the doctor so we forget what she did. She let go. Say it. Make her say it."
"I won't say it," Molly said, "because it isn't true."
Adrian put both hands to his face and stood there for a moment, breathing, with the hall spinning quietly around him — the chandelier, the lilies, the gold dress, the grey uniform, the baby crying in the middle of it all. When he took his hands away, his face was grey.
"Molly," he said. "Molly, tell me the truth. Did you have the handle?"
"I did not have the handle," Molly said. "Celeste took it at the top of the stairs. She said she wanted to hold it for the photograph. I stepped down two steps. My hands were empty. When the stroller moved, I ran. I fell. I stopped it with my body at the bottom. That is the truth. That is all of it."
"She's lying," Celeste said, and her voice was rising again, and there were tears on her face now, real tears, Molly thought, or tears so well practised that the difference no longer mattered. "She's lying and you're standing there listening to her lie about our baby, Adrian. Our baby went down the stairs. Our baby. And you're asking her questions as if this were a — a meeting. As if this were business. She should be out of this house. She should be out of this house tonight. I will not have her near my children. I will not."
"She is not your —" Molly began, and stopped herself. She bit the words back. Ivy was quieting against her shoulder, hiccupping, exhausted, and Molly would not raise her voice over a baby's head. She would not do it. Whatever else happened in this room, she would not do that.
"She is not what?" Celeste said, and she took a step forward, and her face was very close now, and her voice was low and shaking. "Say it. Go on. Say what you were going to say. She is not my what?"
Molly said nothing. She looked at Celeste, and she looked at Adrian, and she looked down at Ivy, and she said nothing at all, and the silence in the hall was suddenly enormous, and into that silence came the sound of running feet from the back of the house, and the kitchen door banging open, and Ada Kowalski arriving in the hall with her apron still on and her hands still wet from the sink.
Ada had worked in this house for twenty years. She had cooked for Helen Marlowe and held Sadie when Sadie was a baby, and she had seen everything there was to see in this house. She had a way of arriving in a room that made the room tell her what had happened before anyone opened their mouth.
She took it all in, in one look: the stroller at the foot of the stairs. Molly on the floor, then standing, holding Ivy. Celeste in gold, pointing. Adrian with his hands to his face. The silence. The crying, subsiding.
"What happened?" Ada said. "Is the baby hurt?"