Celeste had lowered her hands a fraction. They were no longer pressed flat to her face. They hovered now, just below her chin, fingers curled, as if she did not know what to do with them. Her face was pale beneath her makeup. Her eyes were wide and fixed on Molly, and on Ivy, and on the stroller, moving from one to the other and back again, as if she were trying to work out what had happened and could not quite make the pieces fit. Her gold dress shimmered in the chandelier light. Her long earrings swayed, very slightly, as she breathed. She opened her mouth, as if to speak, and then closed it again. No sound came out.
Molly did not speak either. She had nothing to say yet. The words would come later, and there would be a great many of them, from a great many people, and some of them would be angry, and some of them would be lies, and some of them would be the plain truth, spoken by a nine-year-old girl with a phone in her hand. But not yet. Not in these first seconds. In these first seconds, there was only the hall, and the marble, and the baby in her arms, and the silence.
Ivy's crying eased, by degrees, into quiet. Her sobs came further apart. Her small body, which had been rigid with fright, softened against Molly's chest. Her hand, still clutching Molly's apron ribbon, loosened its grip, and then tightened again, as if to make sure Molly was still there. Molly bent her head and kissed the top of Ivy's curls, and whispered to her, and rocked her, and felt the baby's breathing slow and deepen, the way it always did when Ivy was settling, when the world had frightened her and Molly had made it safe again.
"There," Molly whispered. "There you are. Shh. Shh."
From the landing, Sadie watched, and filmed, and did not lower her phone. From the stairs, Celeste stood in her gold dress, with her hands hovering below her chin, and did not come down. On the marble floor, Molly sat with Ivy in her arms, and the empty stroller beside her, and the hall held its breath around them, waiting for someone to move, for someone to speak, for the first word that would break the silence and decide what this evening was going to become.
Nobody moved. Nobody spoke. For a few seconds more, the silence held, complete and waiting, in the beautiful, shining, terrible hall.
Chapter 3: The Blame
For three seconds after the stroller stopped, nobody in the hall moved at all. The sound of the wheels was gone. The crying had not yet begun. There was only the ticking of the tall clock by the front door and the thin hum of the chandelier, and the smell of the lilies Celeste had arranged that afternoon on the console table, sweet and too strong in the still air.
Molly Ferreira lay flat on the marble at the foot of the stairs, one arm thrown across the stroller's black frame, her cheek against the cold floor. Her grey skirt was twisted around her knees. Her white apron had ridden up and one of its strings had come undone. The bun at the back of her head had loosened, and dark strands of hair fell across her face. She did not move. She was listening. She was listening the way she had listened for eight months, in the dark, in the nursery, for the sound a baby makes when it is only frightened and the sound it makes when it is hurt, and the difference between the two, which is everything.
Then Ivy cried.
It was a hard, startled, furious cry, the cry of a baby who has been jolted and frightened and wants the world put right, and Molly's whole body answered it before her mind did. She pushed herself up onto her hands and knees, her palms slipping a little on the polished marble, and reached for the stroller with both hands, feeling for the harness, for the small warm body, for the pink dress. "I've got you," she said. "I've got you, sweetheart. I'm here. I'm here."
Above her, on the stairs, Celeste Marlowe stood with both hands pressed to her face.
She had not come down. That was the first thing Molly registered, even through the crying, even through the pain blooming in her hip and shoulder: Celeste had not come down. She stood halfway up the staircase in her gold dress, her blonde hair perfect, her hands over her mouth, looking down at them — at the stroller, at Molly on the floor, at the baby — the way a person looks at something happening on a stage, something not quite real and not quite hers.
Then her hands came down from her face.
"What have you done?" Celeste said.
Her voice was not loud. It was sharp, and it carried in the marble hall the way a glass carries when it is set down too hard on stone. "What have you done to her? What have you done?"
Molly did not answer. She was unfastening the harness with fingers that shook. Ivy's face was red, her mouth open, her small fists clenched. Molly lifted her out of the stroller, carefully, supporting her head the way she always did, and gathered her against her shoulder, one hand cupping the back of the baby's head, the other spread across her back, feeling the rise and fall of her breathing, feeling for anything wrong. Ivy's crying did not stop, but it changed, the way it always changed when Molly held her: it became a crying that had somewhere to go.