Brenda made a small sound, not quite a word. Okoro looked up at her, then back at Arthur.
"But that doesn't settle the fence," he went on. "The easement is ten feet wide, five feet on either side of the center-line. The post stands inside it. The enclosure stands inside it. The whole run of this fence stands inside it, on both sides. The easement doesn't care about three inches. It covers the post either way."
He drove a wooden stake at the center-line and tied a ribbon to it. Then he drove a second stake at the edge of the easement on Arthur's side, five feet out, and a third on Brenda's side. The three ribbons fluttered in the dry heat.
Okoro stepped back and looked at the line he had marked. "When this subdivision was platted in 1973, the surveyor drew this easement so the utility could reach the main without asking either homeowner's permission. That's what an easement is. It's not a fence line. It's a strip of ground set aside for a purpose, and the purpose doesn't end because the fence went up later."
He pointed at the enclosure on the post. "That box is inside the strip. The post is inside the strip. The retaining wall is inside the strip too, on her side. Whoever built the wall built it inside a recorded easement, which is its own problem, but it's not the problem I was hired to measure."
Arthur nodded. He had walked this line a hundred times and never thought of it as a strip. Now it had edges, marked with stakes and ribbon, and a width he could pace off with his own boots.
"So whose post is it?" Brenda asked. Her voice was thin.
"It is a common post," Okoro said. "It stands in a shared easement, on a shared boundary, holding a shared enclosure. That's what the plat says. I'll put it in writing."
He took photographs of the pin, the post, the stakes, and the tape measure stretched between them. He wrote the numbers in his book in a careful hand: pin to post, three inches; easement width, ten feet; date of the plat, 1973.
Arthur looked at the ribbons. Five feet on his side, five feet on Brenda's. The fence had always been a line between two yards. Now it was a strip ten feet wide, and the post sat in the middle of it, belonging to neither of them and to both.
Brenda stepped closer to the fence, close enough that Arthur could see the dust on her shoes. "So he was allowed to work on it," she said, not quite a question.
"He was allowed to maintain it," Okoro said. "The easement gives both of you the right to maintain what stands inside it. What he can't do is move it off the line without the other owner's agreement. He didn't. He set the new post in the same hole."
Okoro packed his tripod and handed Arthur a copy of his field notes, initialed at the bottom. He handed Brenda the same. She held the paper by its corner, as if it might be hot.
"I'll file the formal survey with the county on Monday," he said. "The recorded plat already says what I measured. This only confirms it."
He drove away, and the ribbons stayed, three small flags in the red clay, marking a line that had been there since before either of them owned their houses.
The county courthouse smelled of old paper and floor wax. Arthur signed the register at the clerk's desk, paid the copy fee in cash, and was directed to a basement room where the plat books lived on steel shelves. A clerk in a cardigan pulled two volumes and set them on the table without a word.
The first was the plat for Copperleaf Estates, recorded in 1973. Arthur found the page with his lot and Brenda's, two rectangles side by side, and ran his finger along the line between them. The surveyor's hand had drawn the easement as a pair of dashed lines, five feet to either side of the center-line, labeled in small capitals: SHARED UTILITY EASEMENT — 10 FT. The line ran the full length of the boundary, from the street to the back fence.
He copied the page at the machine in the hall. The copy came out warm and smelling of toner, and he folded it carefully into his folder.
The second volume was thinner, a book of orders and resolutions. He found the one he was looking for by its date, stamped in the margin: November 14, 1974. An order of the county commission dissolving the Clay County Water Board and transferring its assets and records to the newly formed regional water authority. The language was plain, bureaucratic, final: the board ceased to exist at midnight on December 31, 1974. Its mains, its valves, its paper, all passed to the regional authority.