Mensah looked at the seal on Brenda's meter. She turned it over in her fingers, gently, the way a person handles a thing that might be evidence. She took out a small notebook and wrote down the seal number, and then she took out her phone and looked something up, and then she wrote the number down again, more slowly.
"This seal number," she said, "is not in our records."
Arthur said nothing. He had not touched Brenda's meter. He had not looked at its seal number. He had no reason to know whether it was in the records or not, and he was not going to pretend that he did.
"When was the last time your meter was sealed?" Mensah asked him.
"When it was installed," Arthur said. "I've never had it opened."
She nodded, and she wrote that down, and she went to his meter and looked at its seal, and she wrote that number down too, and she looked it up on her phone, and she nodded again, a smaller nod, the kind a person gives when a number matches.
"Your seal is original," she said. "It's in the records. It matches the installation date."
She turned back to Brenda's meter. "Hers doesn't. Hers is a counterfeit, or it's from another meter, or it's been replaced. I'll need to pull the consumption records for both houses to know more."
Arthur thought about what that meant. Five years of numbers, month by month, two houses side by side. A meter that under-reads leaves a shape in the data, a step down that never steps back up, and a shape like that is harder to argue with than a voice on a back porch. He had seen utility investigators work before, on other jobs, in other counties, and he knew their method: they did not accuse, they did not shout, they simply laid the numbers on the table and waited for the numbers to do the talking.
Brenda had come out of her house and stood on her porch, watching. Mensah walked over to her and asked her, politely, whether she had ever had work done on her meter, and Brenda said no, and Mensah wrote that down, and Brenda's face did not change, but her hands, resting on the porch rail, tightened until her knuckles went white.
The crew finished de-energizing the box and tagged it out, and the lead cable sat in the concrete base of the retaining wall, dull and gray, and the box hung open and empty of current, and Mensah stood at the fence with her clipboard and looked at the two houses and the two meters and the one open box between them, and she said, "We'll pull five years of data for both houses. That will tell us what we need to know."
Arthur watched the bucket truck pull away, and he watched Mensah's car follow it, and he stood at the fence in the cooling air and thought about how a number on a seal, a number that was not in a record, could be the beginning of the whole story.
Night came down on Copperleaf Estates, and Arthur could not sleep.
He lay in bed and listened to the house settle, and to the air conditioner cycling on and off, and to the small sounds of the neighborhood at night: a dog, a car on the street, the distant hum of a transformer. He got up and stood at his bedroom window and looked at the fence line in the dark. The white PVC fence was a pale line against the black yard, and the post stood where it had stood all day, straight and dark, and the box hung on it, open and empty of current, and the padlock dangled from its hinge, catching the porch light now and then when the wind moved it.
He went downstairs and sat at his kitchen table with a pencil and a sheet of paper, and he sketched the box from memory. He drew the enclosure, the door, the hinge, the padlock. He drew the conductors: the black and the red, the split-sheath Romex, the porcelain caps, cracked with age. He drew the splices, the bright copper where the oxidation had not yet taken hold, the heat marks. And he drew the lead-jacketed cable, heavy and dull, running down through the bottom of the box and into the concrete base of Brenda's retaining wall, and he drew the tarnished brass seal stamped on it, and he wrote beneath it, in his neat, careful hand: "Clay County Water Board — 1974."
He sat back and looked at the sketch. He had drawn a hundred boxes in his life, on job logs and on napkins and on the backs of invoices, and he knew how to read a drawing the way he knew how to read a box: by looking for the thing that did not belong.