He thought about the letter for a while after he put it away. The HOA had done what a board is supposed to do: it had received a complaint, asked a question, looked at the paper, and closed the matter. There was no villain in it. The covenants said the fence was a common element, and the easement said the post stood inside a shared strip, and the survey said the post had not moved. All three could be true at once, and the board had been willing to see that. Arthur respected that. He had spent thirty years working under codes and permits, and he knew the difference between a rule that protected people and a rule that was only a habit. The HOA's letter had been a habit. The survey had been the rule.
That evening, Brenda came to the fence. She did not cross to his side. She stood on her side and looked at the ribbons still fluttering on Okoro's stakes.
"Did the HOA write to you too?" she asked.
"They wrote to me," Arthur said. "I answered with the survey."
"Did they write to me?"
"I don't know," Arthur said. "That's between you and the board."
She nodded and went back inside. The ribbons kept fluttering in the heat, three small flags marking a line that the HOA, the surveyor, and the county all agreed on.
Arthur stayed at the fence a little longer, after she had gone. He looked at the letter in his mind, the way the board had backed off without a fight once it saw the survey. That was how paper worked when the paper was right: nobody had to raise their voice. The HOA had sent one letter, Arthur had answered it with the plat and the survey, and the matter was closed. He wished the rest of it would close the same way. The meter, the seal, the graph, the box — they were all paper too, in the end, and paper had a way of settling things that shouting never did. He went inside and put the HOA's second letter on top of the stack in his folder, where it belonged, with the rest of the record.
Mensah called Arthur on a Monday morning and asked him to come to the utility office. When he arrived, she had a single sheet of paper on her desk, and a pen beside it, and the same second monitor showing the same two columns of numbers.
"This is my interim finding," she said. "It's not the final report. The final report comes after the forensic electrician and the prosecutor. But you should hear this now."
She read from the sheet. "The tap is real. A conductor runs from the unmetered service conductors at Mrs. Farrow's meter base, through the old bonding cable, into the common-post box. It powers garden lighting and a shed freezer on her side of the fence."
Arthur nodded. He had already seen the graph. He had already seen the drawings. He was not surprised.
"The tap is on Brenda's side of the meter," Mensah went on. "The meter base it connects to is hers. The freezer it powers is hers. The garden lights are hers. The consumption drop is hers."
She set the sheet down. "And it is not your work, Mr. Sorenson. Your meter seal is original. It's in our records, with the number the installer wrote down when it was fitted. Your consumption is clean — it moves with the seasons, the way a normal house moves. There is no step-change in your column. There is no second seal on your meter. There is no conductor running from your side to the box."
Arthur sat still. He had known, in the way a man knows his own work, that he had not done this. But hearing it from the utility investigator, with the records on the desk between them, was a different thing.
"Whose seal is on her meter, then?" he asked.
Mensah picked up the sheet again. "The seal on Mrs. Farrow's meter is not in our records. The number doesn't exist in our system. It is a counterfeit seal. Someone fitted it to hide the tap."
She folded the sheet and put it in a folder of her own. "I'll send this to Officer Marshfield today. The rest — the dating of the splices, the notebook, the receipt — that's for the next part of the investigation. But the interim finding is this: the tap is real, it is on her side of the meter, and it is not your work."