Mensah nodded. She did not say anything else. She did not need to. The report had done what the consumption curve and the seal had started to do: it had separated the old wire from the new work, and it had put a date on the new work that matched no part of Arthur's life.
Thacker had not worked alone. The report carried the lab's photographs as an appendix: the copper, bright where it had been freshly cut in 2019 and darkened now by five years of oxidation; the wire nuts, heat-marked on one side where the splice had run warm; the Romex insulation, still flexible, its printing legible, with a date code from the late twenty-tens. Beside them were photographs of the porcelain caps, their glaze crazed in a fine network of lines, the ceramic stained brown at the edges where damp had crept in over decades. The contrast, laid out side by side, was the whole case in pictures: new work and old work, sitting in the same box, telling different dates. He had also tested the lead cable for current history. A cable that has carried household load for years shows it along its length. This one showed none of it, except at the single point where it entered the wall, where the arc damage was recent, the metal still bright at the edges of the crack, the soot fresh. It matched Brenda's account of the sparks last Tuesday, and it matched nothing else.
Mensah did not confront Brenda at the house. She asked her to come to the utility office, a plain room with a table, two chairs, and a window that looked out onto the service yard. Brenda came in her floral blouse, her hair combed, her hands folded in her lap. She had been polite to everyone since the morning at the fence, and she was polite now.
Mensah laid out the papers in order, the way she had laid them out for Arthur, for Marshfield, for the prosecutor. First, the consumption curve: five years of meter readings for Brenda's house, printed on a single sheet, the line steady until the summer of 2019, then dropping in a single step and never recovering. Arthur's line, on the sheet beneath it, ran flat and steady across the same five years.
"Your meter under-read from the summer of 2019," Mensah said. "It dropped the month your husband built the retaining wall. It never came back up. That is not a faulty meter. That is a bypass."
Brenda looked at the curve and said nothing.
Second, the seal. Mensah set the counterfeit seal on the table in a small plastic bag, beside a photograph of a genuine utility seal. The numbers did not match any record the utility held. The metal was wrong. The stamping was shallow.
"This seal was not issued by the utility," Mensah said. "It was fitted after the original seal was cut. The number is not in our system. Someone opened your meter base and closed it again with a false seal."
Brenda's hands tightened in her lap.
Third, the report. Mensah opened Thacker's folder and read the conclusion aloud, slowly, without emphasis: the splices date to about 2019; the porcelain caps date to 1974; the Romex is modern; the lead cable never carried current before 2019.
"That is five years of work," Mensah said. "Done in your yard, on your meter, feeding your lights and your freezer. It was not done in 1974. It was not done by the man on the other side of the fence. It was done in 2019, in your house, while your husband was alive."
Brenda was quiet for a long time. The room was quiet with her. Mensah waited. She had learned, in her years as an investigator, that silence does more work than questions, if you let it sit long enough.
Then Brenda lifted her head, and her voice, when it came, was low and steady, and it was the first time in the whole story that she said something that was entirely true.
"Dale did the wiring," she said.
Mensah wrote it down, word for word, in her notebook. She did not press her. She did not ask her to say more. She closed the folder, and she looked at Brenda, and she saw a woman who had carried a small lie for five years — first by saying nothing, then by keeping a circuit running, then by calling the police on the man who had come to look at it — and who had finally, in a plain room with a consumption curve and a false seal on the table, said the one sentence that made the rest of the record make sense.
"Dale did the wiring." It was not an excuse. It was not a defence. It was the truth, and it was enough to begin with.