I sat down, because my legs would not hold me. I thought about Eleanor's diary, about the last page, about the words she had written in her own hand, that she was to meet Marcus Hale the night she died, and that she had been afraid, and that she had written, in the margin, in smaller letters, that if anything happened to her, Claire should know the truth. I had read those words a hundred times since Margaret had given me the diary from Vault 17. I had read them until they were burned into my memory. Eleanor had known she was in danger. She had gone to meet Hale anyway, because she believed she could buy his silence, or because she believed she could reason with him, or because she believed, as I had believed for so long, that if you were honest with a man, he would be honest with you. She had been wrong. Honesty had not saved her. A cut brake line had killed her, on a dark road, in a carriage that would not stop.
Victoria spoke first. Her voice was steady, but her hands were shaking, and she pressed them together in her lap to hide it. She said that she had spent the night thinking, and that she had come to a decision, and that she wanted us to hear it from her, plainly, without any more secrets. She said that she would not marry Alexander. She had told him that already, in the garden, and she meant it still. She did not love him in the way a wife should love a husband, and he did not love her in the way a husband should love a wife, and a marriage built on a lie would be no better than the lie that had killed Eleanor. But she said something else too, something I had not expected. She said that she believed me. She believed that I was Claire Elizabeth Whitmore, that Eleanor had been my twin, that Edmund had wanted us both dead, and that Marcus Hale had killed the wrong sister. She said that she had doubted me at first, because it was easier to doubt a stranger than to believe that the palace she had come to live in was built on a murder, but she had watched Oliver reach for me, and she had watched Margaret weep when she saw my face, and she had read Eleanor's diary, and she could not doubt any longer. And she said that she would not marry Alexander, but she would stand beside him as a witness, and she would tell the truth, in front of anyone who asked, about what she had seen and what she had heard.
I looked at her, and I felt something loosen in my chest, something I had been holding tight since the day I arrived at the palace gates. I had expected Victoria to be my enemy. I had expected her to fight for her wedding, for her place, for her future. Instead she was offering me her hand, not as a rival, but as a witness. I took it. Her hand was cold, and mine was cold too, and for a moment we held on to each other, two women who had both been lied to, and who were both, now, choosing to tell the truth.
Alexander nodded, slowly, as if he had expected this, and as if he were grateful for it, and he said that was enough, that with Victoria as a witness, and with Captain Hart as security, and with Margaret and Beatrice to confirm what they knew, we could do what needed to be done. He turned to Captain Hart, and he asked him, plainly, if he could arrest Marcus Hale quietly, without alerting Edmund, and without frightening the palace, and Hart said yes, that he had already chosen four men he trusted, men who had served under him for years, men who had no connection to Edmund, and that they could take Hale in the stables, where he was alone, and bring him to a small room off the kitchens, where he could be questioned without anyone knowing.
I asked, my voice shaking a little, what would happen if Hale would not talk, and Hart said, very calmly, that men like Hale always talked, when they were frightened enough, and when they understood that they were alone, and that Edmund would not save them. He said that Hale was not a brave man. He was a paid man. Paid men talked when the money ran out, and when the fear ran in. I believed him. I had seen fear in Hale's eyes, in the photograph Margaret had shown me, in the way he had looked at Eleanor's carriage, in the way he had looked at me when I first walked into the palace garden. He was a man who had done a terrible thing for money, and who had lived with it for two years, and who had believed, all that time, that he had killed the hidden twin, and that the secret was safe. Now the secret was standing in front of him, alive, and he would have to face it.
We agreed on the plan, there in the library, with the fire crackling and the morning light coming through the tall windows. Hart and his men would take Hale in the stables, quietly, at noon, when the grooms were at lunch and the yard was empty. They would bring him to the small room, and Alexander and I would be waiting there, with Victoria, and we would ask him, plainly, what he had done, and who had paid him, and why. If he told the truth, we would have what we needed to confront Edmund. If he did not, we would have to find another way. But Hart was certain he would talk. He had seen men like Hale before, and he knew the look in their eyes when they realised they were caught.