Alexander thanked me, quietly, and he did not rush to the next speaker. He let the silence sit for a moment, so that the council could look at the papers on the table, at the two birth certificates, at the transfer order, at the letter, at the brass key, at the diary with the pressed flower, at the sealed envelope with my name on it. I watched their faces as they looked, and I saw disbelief turn to understanding, and understanding turn to anger, and anger turn to grief. One of the older men at the table, a man with white hair and a stern face, picked up the transfer order and read it again, slowly, and then he set it down, and he looked at Beatrice, and he said, "You signed this." Beatrice nodded. She did not look away. "I signed it," she said. "I have said so. I will say it again, as many times as you need to hear it. I signed it, and I have lived with it every day since." The man nodded, slowly, and he sat back in his chair, and he did not speak again. Then Alexander called Captain James Hart.
Captain Hart rose from his place by the door, and he walked to the centre of the room, and he stood straight, his uniform crisp, his face calm, his voice clear and measured, the voice of a man who had spent his life giving reports and who knew how to give one without emotion, even when the facts were terrible. He told the council about Marcus Hale first. He told them that Hale had been arrested two nights earlier, in his rooms in the palace, and that he had confessed, in writing and in person, to cutting the brake line on Eleanor's carriage. He laid Hale's written confession on the table, beside my papers, and he read the relevant part aloud, in Hale's own words, that he had been ordered to do it by Prince Edmund Whitmore, that he had been paid in gold, that he had been told the carriage would crash on the hill road, and that no one would question it, because carriages crashed, and because Eleanor was young, and because accidents happened. He told them that Hale had said he had not known, at the time, that Eleanor was not Claire, that he had believed he was killing the hidden twin, and that he had only learned later, when Edmund had told him, that he had killed the wrong sister. He told them that Hale had wept when he had confessed, and that he had said he would spend the rest of his life trying to atone for it, and that he knew atonement would not be enough.
Then Captain Hart presented the carriage records. He laid them on the table, one by one, the maintenance log, the inspection report, the report from the blacksmith who had examined the carriage after the crash, the report from the doctor who had examined Eleanor's body. He pointed to the line in the maintenance log where the brake line had been marked as sound, only a week before the crash, and to the line in the blacksmith's report where the cut had been described, clean and deliberate, not worn, not frayed, not accidental, but cut with a sharp blade, in a place where no stone could have reached it, in a place where only a man with tools and time could have reached it. He pointed to the doctor's report, which said that Eleanor had died instantly, that she had not suffered, and that there had been no sign of illness, no sign of a heart failure, no sign of anything except the crash. He told the council that the carriage had been examined by three separate men, and that all three had agreed, that the brake line had been cut, and that the cut had caused the crash, and that the crash had caused Eleanor's death. He told them that the records had been kept in the palace archive, and that they had been there all along, waiting for someone to look at them properly, and that no one had looked, because everyone had believed the story of an accident, and because an accident was easier to believe than a murder. When he finished, he stood at attention, and he waited, and Alexander thanked him, and Captain Hart returned to his place by the door, and the room was silent again, and I could hear the clock ticking, and the baby breathing, and my own heart.