Margaret was crying now, quietly, her shoulders shaking. "You told me she was an orphan," she said. "You told me her mother had died, and her father was gone, and that she needed a home. You did not tell me she was a Whitmore. You did not tell me she had a sister. You did not tell me she had a family who would one day come looking for her."
"I could not tell you," Beatrice said. "If I had told you, you would have been in danger too. The fewer people who knew, the safer she was. I watched her from a distance, all those years. I sent money, through lawyers, through friends, through hands that did not know whose money it was. I read the reports Margaret sent, the school reports, the photographs, the letters that said Claire was well, Claire was happy, Claire was safe. And I told myself that I had done the right thing, that I had saved her life, even if I had taken her family from her."
I looked down at Oliver, and I thought about the twenty-six years I had lived without knowing I had a sister, without knowing I had a family, without knowing that the woman who raised me had been given me by a veiled stranger in the night. I thought about Eleanor, my twin, who had grown up in a palace, who had married a prince, who had given birth to a baby, and who had died two years ago, and I wondered if she had known about me, if she had ever looked in a mirror and felt that something was missing, if she had ever dreamed of a sister she had never met.
"Did Eleanor know?" I asked, and my voice was hoarse. "Did my sister know about me? Did she know she had a twin?"
Beatrice looked at me, and her eyes filled with tears. "Yes," she said. "She found out, not long before she died. She found something in Vault 17, under the east wing, a vault that belonged to her, a vault that held the family papers, the will, the letters, the truth about her birth. She came to me, frightened, and she asked me if it was true, if she had a sister, if you were alive. And I told her the truth, because I could not lie to her any longer. I gave her the brass key to Vault 17 the night before she died, because she had found something in the vault, and she was afraid, and she wanted to keep it safe, and she wanted to know what to do next."
Alexander stood up so quickly that his chair scraped across the floor. "You gave my wife a key the night before she died," he said, "and you never told me. You knew she was afraid, and you never told me. You knew she had found something, and you never told me what it was. Grandmother, I loved her. I would have protected her. I would have done anything to keep her safe. Why did you not tell me?"
Beatrice held up her hand, and for a moment she looked very old, and very tired, and very alone. "Because I was afraid," she said. "I was afraid that if I told you, you would bring Claire home, and the man who wanted her dead would find her, and he would finish what he started twenty-six years ago. I was afraid that if I told you about Eleanor's fear, you would go looking for the man who frightened her, and he would kill you too. I was afraid, Alexander, and fear makes cowards of us all, even queens, even grandmothers, even women who have lived long enough to know better."
I held Oliver closer, and I felt his small fingers tighten around mine, and I thought about Eleanor, alone in this palace, frightened, holding a brass key, with no one to tell except an old woman who was afraid to tell anyone else. I thought about the night before she died, and I wondered what she had found in that vault, and whether it had been the thing that killed her, or whether she had died of something else entirely, and the vault had only been the place where she had hidden the truth.
"Did you kill her?" Alexander asked, and the words came out flat and cold, and the room went still. "Grandmother, I must ask you. Did you kill my wife? Did you have anything to do with her death? Because you are telling me that you kept a secret for twenty-six years, and that you gave her a key, and that she was afraid, and that she died the next night, and I need to hear you say, plainly, whether you had anything to do with it."
Beatrice did not look away. She met his eyes, and her voice, when she spoke, was clear and steady. "No," she said. "I did not kill Eleanor. I loved her as I loved my own daughter. I protected her as best I could, and I failed her, and I will carry that failure to my grave. But I did not kill her, and I did not order her death, and I did not know, until it was too late, that she was in danger. If I had known, I would have taken her away, as I took Claire away. I would have hidden her, as I hid her sister. I did not, and I have lived with that every day since."