Edmund laughed then, a short, ugly laugh, and he said that Alexander was a fool, that he had always been a fool, that he had married a woman who was half of a pair, and that he had never understood what that meant, that the trust was meant for a single heir, not for twins, not for a hidden girl raised by a nurse in Baltimore, not for a baby who would grow up and ask questions. He said that he had wanted the trust, yes, that he had wanted it for years, that he had watched his brother, Alexander's father, hold it, and then watched Alexander hold it, and that he had waited, patiently, for his turn, and that when he learned about me, about the hidden twin, he knew that his turn would never come, unless both of us were gone. He said it plainly, without shame, as if it were a reasonable thing to want, as if a trust, a pile of money and land and titles, were worth two young women's lives.
Beatrice stepped forward then, and her voice, when she spoke, was colder than I had ever heard it. She said that Edmund was her son's brother, and that she had loved him, and that she had trusted him, and that he had betrayed that trust in the worst way a man can betray it, by ordering a murder in her house, and by killing a woman who had been like a daughter to her. She said that Eleanor had been kind to him, that she had invited him to dinner, that she had asked after his health, that she had never suspected him, and that he had repaid her kindness with a cut brake line. She said that she would not speak for him, and that she would not protect him, and that he would face a judge, and that the judge would decide his fate, as he had decided Eleanor's, without mercy, and without pity.
Margaret stepped forward too, holding Oliver close, and she said, very quietly, that she had raised me in Baltimore, that she had kept me safe for twenty-six years, that she had watched me grow from a baby into a woman, and that Edmund had tried to take that woman from her, twice, once by ordering her death in a carriage, and once by ordering her death before she was even born, in the sense that he had wanted both twins gone, and that he had failed, both times, because I was standing in front of him, alive, holding my sister's son in my arms, and that no amount of money, no trust, no title, could change that.
I stepped forward last, holding Oliver, who was awake now, looking around with wide eyes, reaching for my face with his small hand, just as he had done in the garden on the day I arrived. I looked at Edmund, and I said, very clearly, so that there could be no misunderstanding, that he had killed the wrong sister. I said that he had ordered Eleanor's death thinking she was Claire, thinking she was the hidden twin come home in secret, and that he had been wrong, and that the sister he had wanted dead was standing in front of him, alive, breathing, holding her sister's son, and that she would not be silent, and that she would not go back to Baltimore, and that she would tell the truth, to Alexander, to Beatrice, to Captain Hart, to Victoria, to anyone who would listen, until the whole world knew what he had done.
Edmund looked at me, and for a moment his face crumpled, as if he were going to cry, or to beg, or to deny it all over again, and then he straightened, and he said, very coldly, that it did not matter, that I was still a hidden twin, that no one would believe a nurse's girl from Baltimore, that the palace would protect its own, that Alexander would not dare to make this public, because it would shame the family, and shame the crown, and shame Oliver. He said that I should take the money in the bag, and go back to Baltimore, and forget Eleanor, and forget the trust, and live quietly, as I had always lived, and that if I did, he would leave me alone, and if I did not, he would find another Hale, and another brake line, and this time he would make sure it was me.
Alexander did not answer him at first. He stood very still in the doorway, looking at his uncle, at the bag of money on the desk, at the pistol beside it, at the letter from Hale lying open in the light, and I could see the grief moving across his face, grief for Eleanor, grief for Oliver, grief for the family he had thought he knew, and then, underneath the grief, a hardness I had not seen in him before, the hardness of a man who has finally understood that the person in front of him is not family any more, but a criminal who happens to share his blood.
He said, very quietly, that Edmund was wrong, that the palace would not protect a murderer, that the crown would not be shamed by the truth, that it would be shamed by a lie, and that Oliver would grow up knowing that his father had chosen the truth, even when the truth was terrible, even when it hurt the family, even when it meant arresting his own uncle in his own house. He said that he would not take Edmund's money, and that I would not take it either, and that Edmund would not be allowed to leave this room except in the custody of Captain Hart, and that he would be tried, in public, for what he had done, and that the whole world would know, not just the palace, not just the family, but everyone, because Eleanor deserved that, and because I deserved that, and because Oliver deserved to grow up in a house where a murder was called a murder.