Daniel walked out to look at the fence. It was the same fence he had stained himself, on a Saturday, with Jordan handing him the brush and Amara bringing him water. The color had not changed. The boards had not changed. The only thing that had changed, as far as Daniel could tell, was that he had filed a records request and asked questions about invoices in public. He did not say that in his appeal letter, because he could not prove it from a fence, and Daniel did not write things he could not prove. He wrote what he could prove: the date the fence was stained, the color used, the photographs from previous years showing the same fence, and the fact that no one had raised the color before.
The rain barrel was simpler, and also stranger. It was a blue plastic barrel, with a lid, beside the garage, connected to a downspout, used to water tomatoes. Daniel had bought it at a hardware store, and he still had the receipt, under $50, in a drawer with other small receipts. He photographed it, he measured it, he noted where it stood, and he wrote that it had stood there for three years without complaint. He asked, in writing, which rule it violated, and when that rule had been adopted, and whether other rain barrels in the neighborhood had received the same notice.
Amara helped him with the letters that evening. She was practical about it, in the way she was practical about everything, and she said, "They are trying to tire you out, Daniel. A fine here, a fine there, a letter every few weeks, until asking questions feels more expensive than stopping." Daniel said she might be right, and he said he was tired already, and then he said he would answer anyway, because stopping would also be expensive, in a different way, and he did not want Jordan to learn that a letter was enough to make a person quiet.
The answers came back separately. The fence fine was withdrawn, like the van fine, without explanation and without apology. The rain barrel fine was not withdrawn, but it was reduced to a warning, which meant no money was due, but a note would stay on Daniel's file. Daniel read both letters to Amara, and she said, "So the fence was fine all along, and the barrel is a warning for something that was fine for three years." Daniel nodded. He put all six letters — three fines, two withdrawals, one warning — in the folder, in date order, and he wrote in his notebook: Three fines, $150 each. Two withdrawn. One reduced to warning. He did not write that he was being retaliated against, because the letters did not say that, and Daniel was careful with words he could not prove. But that night, when Amara asked him how he felt, he said, honestly, "Tired, but not finished." Amara said that was a good place to be, tired but not finished, and she made tea, and they sat on the porch until the light went down, and the fence stood behind them, the same color it had always been, and the barrel sat beside the garage, collecting nothing that night, because it had not rained.
Chapter 13: Tom Delgado
Tom Delgado came to Daniel's house on a Sunday afternoon, without calling first, carrying a small tin of biscuits his neighbor had given him, and he sat on the porch and talked the way a man talks when he has decided, after a long time, to say something he should have said years earlier. Tom was sixty-eight, retired from the fire service, broad-shouldered and gray-haired, and he had lived across the green from Daniel for most of the time Daniel had lived in Willowbend. He was blunt, but he was not loud, and in meetings people listened to him because he did not raise his voice to make a point. Daniel had always liked him for that, and for the way Tom waved at Jordan when Jordan mowed his lawn, and for the way he kept his own fence mended without making a project of it.
"I heard about the fines," Tom said, after they had talked about the weather and about a leaking tap Tom had fixed himself and was quietly proud of. "The van, the fence, the barrel. I heard about all three." Daniel nodded, and he did not ask how Tom had heard, because news in Willowbend traveled the way it traveled everywhere, through kitchens and driveways and the line at the clubhouse office. Tom set the tin on the porch rail and said, "Years ago, I questioned a paving contract. It was not a large thing. I asked why one company got the work every time, and why the price went up each year, and whether anyone had asked another company. I got a fine for a mailbox post. My mailbox post had been there for twelve years. It was the wrong height, suddenly, or the wrong color, suddenly. I cannot remember which, because it did not matter. What mattered was that I stopped asking."