In the tenth week, Maya asked Daniel for one more document: the list of fourteen homes where Daniel and Priya had found duplicate billing, or work billed as replacement when only a patch or a paint job had been done. Daniel brought the list, with addresses, job numbers, and short notes, and Maya checked each entry against the contractor files she had requested. She did not tell Daniel what she had found. She thanked him, and she said the report would be delivered to the board, and to the members, in the eleventh week, and that she would present it herself, in plain language, at a board meeting. Daniel left the small room at the clubhouse, walked out onto the green, and stood for a moment in the late summer light, thinking about eleven weeks of waiting, and about how a neighborhood, like a pipe, either held pressure or it did not, and that soon they would know which kind of neighborhood Willowbend was.
Chapter 26: The Audit Arrives
The one hundred and eighty-seven-page audit arrived on a Tuesday, in a bound volume, with a cover page, a table of contents, and a summary at the front written in plain language, the way Maya had promised. Daniel received his copy at the clubhouse, from Ana, who handed it to him with both hands, as if it were heavy, which it was, in both senses. He carried it home, set it on the kitchen table, and read the summary first, slowly, with Amara beside him and Priya's timeline open next to it for comparison. The summary was clear, and it did not use language Daniel could not understand. It said, in order, what Maya had found, and Daniel read each finding aloud, quietly, so that Amara could hear it, too.
First, there had been no competitive bids for the three largest contracts. The board had approved the work under emergency authority, but the audit found no bid list, no comparison of prices, and no written record that any other company had been asked to price the work. Second, there had been duplicate billing on fourteen homes, the same count Daniel and Priya had reached on their own, confirmed now by an outsider with access to bank records and contractor files. Third, there had been work at the president's house, billed to the association, in the amount of nine thousand eight hundred dollars, for landscaping that matched, in description and in timing, the work Jordan had photographed from the public path: the stone border, the replanted beds, the repaired patio. Fourth, there had been charges, in the amount of sixty-three thousand four hundred dollars, with no completion photographs and no sign-off sheets, charges for work that could not be verified from the record, however the work itself might be described. Maya's summary did not accuse anyone of a crime. It did not use words the evidence could not support. It laid out, page by page, what was missing, what was duplicated, and what was charged without proof, and it left the conclusions to the board and to the members.
Maya presented the findings herself, at a board meeting the following evening, in the clubhouse, with residents filling the chairs again, though fewer than at the special meeting, and quieter, as if the room knew that this meeting was about numbers, not speeches. Maya stood at the front, with the bound audit on the table beside her, and she spoke in plain language, the way she had written the summary. She explained what a bid was, and why it mattered, and what a sign-off sheet was, and why its absence mattered. She explained duplicate billing with an example, using no names, only job numbers, and she explained the president's house charge by reading the association account line and then describing the work, without embellishment. She answered questions patiently, and when she did not know an answer, she said which page of the audit would help, and she turned to that page, and she read it aloud. Nora Whitfield sat beside her, taking notes, and Tom sat in the front row, listening, and Ruth sat beside Tom, her folder on her lap, closed for once, because the audit had said, in formal language, what her folder had said all along in letters and invoices.
Geraldine Marsh sat at the board table, listening, her hands folded, her face composed, and when Maya finished, Geraldine said that emergency work was difficult, that the board had acted quickly, and that paperwork had lagged behind the work, as it always did in an emergency. She did not dispute a specific number. She did not point to a page and say it was wrong. She spoke generally, about speed and property values and the difficulty of managing a neighborhood after a storm, and Daniel, listening, understood that a general answer, in a room full of specific numbers, sounded thinner than it had sounded months earlier, when there had been no audit to compare it against. Frank Loomis said nothing. He looked at his papers, and then at the table, and then at the door, and Daniel thought that Frank looked like a man who had signed papers quickly for a long time and was only now reading them slowly.