The HOA President Rigged the Repair Contracts — Then a Plumber Read the Invoices

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Inside, Ana Ruiz was at the small desk by the entrance, sorting mail into pigeonholes. She looked up, smiled, and then saw the folder, and her smile became careful, the way people's smiles became careful around board business. Daniel set the folder down and said he was delivering a petition for a special meeting, signed by residents, and that he would like a receipt in writing. Ana nodded and reached for the logbook. She wrote the date and the time, and she wrote his name, and she asked how many signatures there were. Daniel said ninety-six.

"Ninety-six," Ana repeated, writing the number down. She did not ask to see them. She did not need to. But Daniel opened the folder anyway and showed her the first page, where Ruth's name stood at the top in her careful handwriting, and Tom's name stood second, and then page after page of names he had collected at kitchen tables, on porches, and at the ends of driveways. Some signatures were firm and straight. Some were shaky. One was written in pencil because the man who signed it had come out of his garage with a pencil behind his ear and had not wanted to go back inside for a pen. Daniel had not asked anyone to sign quickly. He had asked them to read the request first. The request was simple: a special meeting of the members, called to discuss the storm repair contracts, the invoices, and the records that had not been produced.

Ana gave him a receipt slip, signed it, and slid it across the desk. Daniel folded it once and put it in his shirt pocket. He thanked her. Ruth thanked her. Tom nodded. They walked back out into the morning, and for a few steps none of them spoke, because the hard part, the part that had taken weeks of knocking and listening, was done, and the next part belonged to the board.

The board's answer came three days later, in a letter that was not quite a refusal and not quite an acceptance. Geraldine Marsh wrote that the board would review the petition for validity, that some signatures might belong to residents who were not members in good standing, that some addresses might be unclear, and that the board needed time to confirm each name against its records. She did not give a date for the meeting. She said the board would advise residents in due course. Daniel read the letter twice at his kitchen table, and Amara read it over his shoulder, and Jordan, home from mowing a lawn, read the last paragraph aloud and said it sounded like a way of saying no without saying the word.

Daniel did not answer the letter with anger. He answered it the way Priya had taught him to answer board letters: in writing, with a copy kept, with the facts stated plainly and nothing else added. He wrote that the petition contained ninety-six signatures, that the bylaws promised members access to financial records and a special meeting when members requested one, and that he would like the meeting date in writing. He delivered the letter to Ana the next morning and asked for another receipt. Ana gave it to him, and she did not meet his eye for long, but she did not look away either, and Daniel understood that she was caught between her job and her judgment, and that it cost her something to keep handing him receipts.

Nora Whitfield called that evening. She was the newest board member, and she spoke quietly, as if she were standing in a room where someone else might hear. She said she had asked for the same documents Daniel had asked for, and she had been given summaries instead of invoices. She said she had asked, at the last board meeting, when the special meeting would be called, and Geraldine had said the board was still checking signatures. Nora said she had then read the bylaws herself, word by word, and that the bylaws required a meeting within thirty days of a valid petition. She said she would say so at the next board meeting, in the open, and that Daniel should not worry about whether the meeting would happen. Daniel thanked her, and after he hung up he sat for a while with his hands around a mug of coffee that had gone cold, thinking about how much easier it was to keep going when one person inside the room was willing to read the rules aloud.

The date was set the following week. A notice went up on the clubhouse board and into mailboxes: a special meeting, at the clubhouse, on a Thursday evening, to discuss the storm repair contracts and the association's financial records. The notice was short. It did not mention Daniel by name. It did not mention Pinnacle Grounds. It said only that members were invited to attend and that questions would be taken from the floor. Daniel read it twice, folded it, and put it in his notebook, behind the page where he had written the number ninety-six and circled it. Amara read it and said, "Good. Now we prepare." Ruth called to say she had seen the notice and that she would be there, and Tom called to say the same, and by the end of the day Daniel had a list, not of speeches, but of people who had promised to come, and that list felt steadier than any argument.

News in the same category

The HOA President Rigged the Repair Contracts — Then a Plumber Read the Invoices

45 Part