The HOA President Rigged the Repair Contracts — Then a Plumber Read the Invoices

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

yet confirmed by a photograph. By the middle of the month, the confirmed list had reached fourteen homes, and Daniel stared at that number for a long time, because fourteen was not a mistake. A mistake was one house. A mistake was a wrong gutter, or a missed board, or a typist putting the wrong number on the wrong line. Fourteen was a pattern, and Daniel wrote that word in his notebook, under the list, and he underlined it, not for emphasis, but because he wanted to be sure, later, that he had used it carefully.

Each case, on its own, was small. A fence board billed as a section. A gutter length billed as a replacement. A patch billed as a full slope. A shed billed twice. A drainage ditch billed as grading, when the ditch had only been cleared of leaves. Daniel visited each home himself, or with Tom, and he photographed the work, and he compared the photograph to the invoice, and he wrote down the difference in plain language, without adjectives, because adjectives could be argued with, but a photograph of a patched roof next to an invoice for a full replacement could not be argued with in the same way. Sam's roof was on the list, and Ruth's gutters, and the Hendersons' shed, and eleven other homes whose owners had said yes at their kitchen tables, and whose invoices Daniel now held in copies, in a folder that grew thicker every week.

Priya did the arithmetic, because Daniel asked her to, and because she was good at it, and because she did not enjoy it, which made her careful. She added the overbilled amounts, and she checked them twice, and she told Daniel the total, and Daniel wrote it down, and then he put the notebook away, because the total was not the point he wanted to make in public. The point he wanted to make was simpler: fourteen homes, fourteen invoices, fourteen differences between what was billed and what was done, and one company on every invoice. That was a sentence a resident could understand without knowing anything about roofing or gutters or accounting, and Daniel practiced saying it aloud, at the kitchen table, until Amara said it sounded like him, plain and steady, and not like a lawyer, and not like a man trying to win an argument.

Amara asked him, that evening, whether fourteen frightened him, and Daniel said it did, a little, because fourteen meant the problem was bigger than he had thought, and because bigger problems attracted bigger resistance. She asked him whether he wanted to stop at fourteen, and he said no, because stopping at fourteen would mean leaving other homes uncounted, and because the list had grown by people trusting him with their invoices, and trust, once given, had to be honored by finishing the work. He did not say he was brave, because he did not feel brave. He felt tired, and careful, and stubborn, and those three things, together, were enough to keep him going to the next door, and the next kitchen table, and the next invoice, until the list was complete, or until someone with more authority than a plumber with a notebook took the list from his hands and did something with it.

Chapter 16: The President's Garden

Jordan noticed it first, because Jordan mowed lawns in the neighborhood in the summer, and because a boy who mows lawns notices other people's lawns, and the crews working on them, in the way a plumber notices pipes. He came home one afternoon, hot and grass-stained, and he told his father that Pinnacle crews had been working at Geraldine Marsh's house for days, and that the work was not a small repair. There was a new stone border around the beds, he said, and the beds themselves had been replanted, and the patio at the back had been repaired, with new slabs where the old ones had cracked. Daniel listened, and he asked Jordan how he knew, and Jordan said he had walked past on his way to another lawn, and he had seen the crew, and the stone, and the plants, and he had thought it was a large job for a house that had not reported storm damage that Daniel knew about.

Daniel did not go to Geraldine's house. He did not knock on her door, and he did not step onto her property, because he had decided, early on, that the work had to be clean, and that entering a neighbor's garden to prove a point would make the point dirty. Instead, the next morning, he walked along the public path that ran behind her house, with his phone in his pocket and his tape measure in his hand, and he photographed what could be seen from the path: the stone border, the replanted beds, the repaired patio, the crew's van with the Pinnacle name on its side. He took the photographs from the path only, and he noted the date and time, and he walked home, and he did not speak to anyone on the crew.

News in the same category

The HOA President Rigged the Repair Contracts — Then a Plumber Read the Invoices

45 Part