The HOA President Rigged the Repair Contracts — Then a Plumber Read the Invoices

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

When his turn came, Daniel stood, and he read his questions aloud, calmly, and he handed the sheet to the board secretary, so that there would be a written record of what he had asked. He asked, first, for the Pinnacle Grounds contract, in full, not a summary. He asked, second, for the bid list for the storm repairs, showing which companies had been asked to bid, and what they had quoted. He asked, third, for the sign-off sheets for his street, showing who had inspected the work, and when, and what they had found. He sat down, and the room was quiet, in the way a room is quiet when people are waiting to see how a question will be answered, and whether it will be answered at all.

Geraldine answered first, and she answered smoothly, as she always did, with the certainty of a woman who had presided over meetings for six years and had learned how to make an answer sound complete even when it was not. She said that emergency work did not need bids, because emergencies, by their nature, required speed, and that the board had acted quickly to protect homes after the hailstorm, and that residents should be grateful for that speed, rather than questioning it after the fact. She said that contracts were complex documents, and that summaries were provided to members for their convenience, and that full contracts contained commercial details that were not appropriate for general circulation. She did not say when the full contract would be produced, and she did not say whether a bid list existed, and she did not mention the sign-off sheets at all.

Frank Loomis looked away while she spoke, down at his papers, then out of the window, then back at his papers, and Daniel noticed it, because Daniel noticed small things, and because a treasurer who would not meet a resident's eye while his president answered a question about money was, in Daniel's experience, a man who did not want to be asked the same question next. No other board member spoke, except one, who said that Daniel's questions were noted, and the board voted, quickly, to "note" Daniel's questions without answering them, which meant, in the language of meetings, that the questions had been heard, and recorded, and set aside, all at the same time.

Tom stood then, briefly, and he spoke in his low, steady voice, and he said that he had lived in Willowbend for many years, and that he had once stopped asking questions, and that he regretted it, and that he hoped the board would answer Daniel, because answering was easier than noting, and because residents who received answers stopped worrying, while residents who received notes kept worrying, and kept asking. He sat down, and the room was quiet again, and Geraldine thanked him, politely, and moved on to the next item on the agenda, which was about the clubhouse roof, and which no one in the room, except perhaps Daniel, found interesting that night.

Daniel walked home with Tom and Ruth, in the dark, along the path by the green, and Ruth said, "They noted us, Daniel. They did not answer us, but they noted us, and that is on the record now." Tom said, "A note is a start. A note means they heard you, even if they wish they had not." Daniel nodded, and he thought about the three questions, still unanswered, and about the folder in his hand, still full, and about the fact that a meeting could end without an answer and still move something forward, because the people in the rows behind him had heard the questions, too, and they would remember them, even if the board did not answer them that night. He wrote in his notebook, when he got home: Second meeting. Questions asked in writing. Emergency work, no bids, said Geraldine. Questions noted, not answered. Tom spoke. That was the record of the evening, plain and true, and Daniel put the notebook away, and he slept, and the next morning he went back to work, because plumbing, unlike meetings, usually gave you an answer you could see.

Chapter 18: A Petition Takes Shape

Nora Whitfield found Daniel after the second meeting, not in the clubhouse, but in the parking area, where the light was dim and the air smelled of rain that had not yet fallen. She was thirty-six, a graphic designer, and a newer member of the board, elected midway through the story of Willowbend's troubles, although she did not think of it as a story yet, only as a series of meetings that had begun to trouble her. She spoke quietly, and she looked around before she spoke, not because she was ashamed, but because she had learned, as a newer board member, that asking for documents in a meeting could be met with summaries, and that summaries were not the same as documents, and that saying so aloud could make a meeting uncomfortable.

"I have asked too," she told Daniel, in a low voice, "and I have been given summaries instead. I asked for the full Pinnacle contract, and I received a two-page summary. I asked for the bid list, and I received a note saying emergency work does not require one. I asked for the sign-off sheets, and I received a list of homes said to be complete, without photographs." Daniel listened, and he did not interrupt, and he thanked her, because he understood what it cost a board member to say, to a resident, that she too had been given summaries instead of documents. Nora said she did not want to be a hero, and Daniel said he did not need a hero, and she smiled, briefly, and said, "Good, because I am only a board member who likes to read the whole document before she votes on it."

News in the same category

The HOA President Rigged the Repair Contracts — Then a Plumber Read the Invoices

45 Part