schools and a courthouse with columns, and people who spoke in the brisk, certain tones of a town that knew what it was. Iron Creek valley had a creek, and a road, and a smithy with smoke coming out of its chimney, and a wind that moved through the grass as if it owned the place. Lydia stepped down from the coach with dust on her skirts and her heart beating too fast, and she stood for a moment looking at the smithy, trying to imagine the woman who lived there, and whether that woman would help her or send her away.
She had rehearsed the conversation all the way from Laramie, on the train and then on the stage, turning the sentences over in her mind until they were smooth. She had spent ten years rehearsing, in truth, ever since the morning the verdict had come and her father had been taken away, and she had gone back to her schoolroom and taught other people's children their letters while her own life narrowed to a single purpose. Her father's letters had come twice a month, regular as the seasons, written in a careful hand on prison paper, and they had never once asked her to fight for him. He wrote about the weather inside the walls, and the books he was allowed, and the garden the prisoners kept, and he asked about her pupils, and he told her to live her life and not to grieve a man who was still alive. Lydia had read those letters at her kitchen table in Laramie, and she had obeyed him in everything except the one thing that mattered: she had not stopped fighting. She had written to lawyers, and to the governor's office, and to anyone who would listen, and most of them had not listened, until a new pardon board had been formed and a hearing had been promised, and a clerk had given her the list of names from the summer of 1878. Ada Sorensen's name had been on that list, beside the word "cook," and Lydia had stared at it for a long time, because a cook was a witness the trial had never called, and a witness never called was a door never opened.
She had written to Ada twice, careful letters, respectful letters, explaining who she was and what she wanted, and she had received no answer to either, and she had told herself that the silence might mean many things — that the letters had gone astray, that Ada was busy, that Ada did not wish to be troubled. She had not allowed herself to believe the simplest explanation, which was that Ada did not want to help. Now, standing in the dust of the valley road with her satchel in her hand, she allowed herself to believe it for a moment, and then she set it aside, because belief was not evidence, and she had come too far to turn back on a feeling. She walked toward the smithy with her shoulders straight and her petition held close, the way she walked into her schoolroom every morning, as if confidence were a thing you could put on like a coat, and hope that no one would notice how thin it was. Her father, Tom Beckett, had been in prison for ten years, convicted of causing the collapse of a mine tunnel in 1878 through negligence in inspecting the supports. He had always said he was innocent, and Lydia had always believed him, because a daughter believes her father until the world gives her a reason not to, and the world had never given her a reason, only a verdict. Ten years was a long time to believe something without proof, and Lydia had spent those ten years teaching other people's children while she waited for a chance to prove it. The chance had come in the form of a pardon petition, and a hearing, and a list of names — the people who had been at the mining camp in the summer of 1878, and who might know what had really happened in the tunnel that night. One of those names was Ada Sorensen, who had cooked for the camp that summer and now kept a smithy in Iron Creek valley. Lydia had written to her twice, and received no answer, and so she had come in person, because some questions cannot be asked by letter, and some answers cannot be refused to a face.