The smithy was smaller than she had imagined, and more alive. The forge roared behind the open door, and the anvil stood on its stump in the yard, and a woman stood at the workbench with a hammer in her hand, looking at Lydia with the wary, measuring eyes of a person who is used to strangers wanting something from her. The woman was forty or so, strong in the shoulders, with hair going grey at the temples and hands that looked as if they had done hard work for a long time. She wore a leather apron over a plain dress, and she did not smile, but she did not frown either. She simply waited, the way a woman waits when she has learned that most visitors will say what they came to say soon enough.
"Miss Sorensen?" Lydia said, and her voice came out steadier than she felt. "My name is Lydia Beckett. I've come from Laramie. I wrote to you twice. I don't know if my letters reached you."
"They reached me," Ada said, and her voice was low and even. "I read them. I didn't answer because I had no answer to give."
Lydia felt her rehearsed sentences scatter like papers in the wind, and she reached into her satchel for the petition instead, because the petition was a thing she could hold. "My father is Tom Beckett," she said. "He was the foreman at the mine in 1878. He was convicted of negligence after the tunnel collapsed, and he has been in prison for ten years. I am petitioning for a pardon, and for a hearing, and I am asking the people who were there that summer to say what they saw. You were the camp cook that summer. You were there. I'm asking you to testify that my father did not cause the collapse — that he inspected the supports as he was supposed to, and that something else, someone else, was responsible."
Ada did not move. She stood with the hammer in her hand, and Lydia saw her knuckles whiten around the handle, and her face go very still, the way a person's face goes still when they are trying not to show what they feel. For a long moment the only sound was the forge and the wind and a horse stamping in the corral.
"I can't help you," Ada said at last, and her voice was quiet, almost gentle, which made it worse. "I'm sorry, Miss Beckett. I was the cook. I cooked, and I kept to the kitchen, and I saw nothing that would help your father. I don't know what happened in that tunnel, and I won't swear to something I don't know."
"But you were there," Lydia said, and she heard the pleading in her own voice and hated it, and said it anyway, because pleading was all she had left. "You lived in that camp all summer. You must have heard something, seen something. My father is not a negligent man. He checked those supports himself, every morning, and he wrote it in his log. The log was never found, or never shown at the trial, and the company said he was careless, and the jury believed them because he was the foreman and someone had to be blamed. If you could only say that he did his work, that he was careful —"
"I can't," Ada said, and this time her voice was firmer, and she set the hammer down on the workbench with a care that looked like control. "I won't lie for a stranger, Miss Beckett, and I won't guess at a man's guilt or innocence ten years after the fact. Your father has my sympathy. He does not have my testimony, because I have none to give."
Lydia stood there with the petition in her hands, feeling the valley wind move through her skirts and the smithy smoke drift across the yard, and she understood, with a clarity that hurt, that she had been refused — not cruelly, but completely, by a woman who had decided before she arrived. She thought about arguing further, about showing Ada her father's letters, about reading aloud the passages where her father wrote that he forgave whoever had been afraid that night, whoever had seen something and said nothing. She had the letters in her satchel, and she had meant to show them, but now, looking at Ada's face, she could not bring herself to use them as a weapon. A daughter does not trade her father's forgiveness for a stranger's guilt, even when she is desperate, and Lydia was desperate, but she was not cruel.