The Man Who Had Learned to Live Alone

Chapter 20

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Ada turned away then, and put her hands on the anvil, and bowed her head over it, and Lydia saw her shoulders shake once, hard, and then still. She did not go to her. She had learned, in her years of teaching, that there are griefs a person must be allowed to have alone, even in a room with someone else in it, and that the kindest thing is often to stand still and let the silence do its work.

 

"He forgave me before he knew there was anything to forgive," Ada said, after a long time, and her voice was raw, as if she had been shouting, though she had barely spoken above a whisper. "That is the worst of it, Lydia. Not that he blames me. That he doesn't. That he built his whole peace on a mistake, and my silence is the foundation of it. If I speak now, I take his peace away, too."

 

"Or you give him the truth of it," Lydia said. "Which is not the same thing as peace, I know. But it is the thing he asked for, in his way. He has spent ten years forgiving a stranger. Would you not rather he forgave you, knowingly, and was free of it? And would you not rather be forgiven knowingly, and be free of it yourself?"

 

Ada did not answer, and Lydia, who had said more than she meant to, laid the letters on the workbench beside a horseshoe still warm from the fire, and stepped back toward the door, giving the woman room the way you give a skittish horse room: not by leaving, but by not crowding.

 

"I am not asking you to decide today," Lydia said. "The hearing is not for a fortnight. But I am asking you to read them. All of them. Not just that one. He writes about you more than you think — not by name, but by the place you held in that camp. The woman who fed them. The woman who kept them alive through the winter before it happened. He remembers you kindly, Miss Sorensen. He remembers you as a good woman. I would like him to go on remembering you that way, and to have it be true."

 

She left then, because staying longer would have been pressing, and she walked back through Iron Creek with the autumn sun on her face and her heart beating in a way that felt like hope and dread braided together, and she thought about her father in his cell, writing letters to a daughter who was trying, with all her might, to bring him home — and about the woman in the smithy who held, in her two hands, the only key there was, and was afraid to turn it because the door it opened might be the door of her own house, swinging shut behind her.

 

Ada did not read the letters at once. She worked until noon, shoeing a dray horse for a teamster from Aspen Fork, and her hands did their work the way they always did, by memory and by feel, while her mind went around and around the same small track: he thinks I was asleep; he forgives whoever was afraid; he does not know it was me. At noon she ate standing up, bread and cold meat, and then she sat on her stool by the forge with the packet in her lap and untied the twine, and read.

 

There were eleven letters, spanning ten years, and they told the story of a man in prison the way only letters can: not in grand statements, but in small, stubborn details. The cold in the cell in January. The chaplain who taught him to read Greek, badly. The garden he was allowed to tend, and the tomatoes he grew and gave away, because a man who grows something and gives it away is still a man who provides. The young prisoner in the next cell who cried at night, and whom Tom had taught to whittle, because whittling gave his hands something to do besides shake. And always, once in every letter, the collapse: not bitter, not raging, but puzzled, the way a man is puzzled by a knot he cannot untie. He had inspected the beam himself that morning. He had tapped it and listened. It was solid. He had written it down. And yet it had broken. He did not understand it, and he had stopped trying to understand it, and had turned instead to the only understanding that let him sleep: that someone, somewhere, had been afraid, and that fear, not malice, had done the work. Forgiving that person was the only way he had found to forgive the mountain.

News in the same category

The Man Who Had Learned to Live Alone

45 Part