By the end of that evening we had a log. It was not a dramatic document. It was a table in a notebook and then in a spreadsheet David made, with columns for date, start time, end time, number of vehicles, type of movement, weather, moon phase, and notes. The moon phase mattered, because a bright moon washes out faint lights and a dark moon makes them stand out, and I wanted anyone who read the log later to know I had thought about that. The weather mattered, because cloud changes what a camera sees. The notes column was where I wrote what I had actually observed in plain language: headlights moving west to east along the upper slope, stationary lights for forty minutes, a vehicle turning with its reverse lights showing, a long machine making repeated passes. There were nine nights with activity in the three weeks of footage, and on three of those nights the activity lasted more than an hour. The earliest start was just after midnight. The latest end was a little before four in the morning. On none of those nights was there any notice to residents, any board announcement, any maintenance schedule posted at the trailhead that I had seen. The land was closed, and at night it was busy.
David looked at the log when we were done, and then he looked at the ridge through the back window, though by then it was dark and there was nothing to see but the line of it against the stars. He said what I had been thinking since the third viewing and had not yet said aloud, because saying it aloud made it a claim about a motive and not just an observation. He said my telescope was the only viewpoint in Willow Ridge that looked over that ridge into that land. He said it slowly, the way an engineer states a geometric fact, and the geometry was simple enough that I felt foolish for not having drawn it sooner. The houses on Larkspur Lane sit below the ridge. Their backyards look up at it. Their fences stop at it. The trailheads are at the ends of the subdivision, and from them you see the slope, not what lies beyond it. My backyard is higher than most, because our lot rises toward the back, and my telescope pad is at the highest usable point of it, and the telescope itself, on its mount, puts a camera several feet above the fence line. Add the time-lapse habit, add a camera that runs all night while the neighbourhood sleeps, and you have the only resident in Willow Ridge who is routinely, innocently, recording the ground beyond the ridge while aiming at the sky. Carolyn did not need to hate astronomy to want the telescope gone. She needed a viewpoint gone. A fine of two hundred dollars, then two hundred and fifty dollars a day, then a threat of seizure, was a very expensive way to deal with an eyesore. It was a very cheap way to deal with a witness.
The next morning I walked the ridge boundary, staying on the public side of the line, to see what the ground itself would tell me. The first thing I noticed was the dust. In daylight the slope above the trail looked dry and ordinary, the way high desert looks in late autumn, but in the shallow draws where water would run after a rain there was a fine, pale dust that had been disturbed recently, not by wind, which leaves a pattern like ripples, but by tyres, which leave a pattern like writing. I photographed the tyre tracks where they crossed the trail's edge, taking care to include a fixed reference in each frame, a rock, a fence post, a sign, so that scale and place could not later be argued away. I photographed the sign itself, the erosion control sign, its paint faded but its wording clear, and I photographed the chain across the old service track, which hung slack in a way that suggested it had been unhooked and rehooked often enough that the links had worn smooth at the contact point. Further along, where the slope flattened into a bench above the closed land, I found the tracks more clearly: dual rear wheels, heavy, the tread pattern of a work truck rather than a passenger vehicle, turning in a wide arc as if the driver had manoeuvred in a confined space. Beside them were the fainter, broader marks of something tracked or bladed, a long scrape in the dust that ran parallel to the slope and then stopped, as if a blade had been lifted at the end of a pass. I did not touch anything. I photographed, I noted the time on my phone for each photograph so the metadata would carry it, and I kept walking.