That is why the letter, when it came, felt so strange in my hands, as if it belonged to a different house on a different street. It arrived on a Tuesday in late September, tucked between a catalog for garden supplies and a flyer for a community yard sale, in a plain white envelope with the Willow Ridge Estates Homeowners Association letterhead printed in dark green at the top, and Carolyn Whitmore's name typed neatly beneath it as president. I opened it standing at the kitchen counter, Rose beside me rinsing a mug, and I read it twice because the first time I thought I had misread it. The letter said that the association had received a complaint concerning a structure in our backyard, that the structure in question was a large telescope and associated camera equipment, that it violated Section 7.4 of the community covenants concerning structures and sightlines, and that we were required to remove it within fourteen days and pay a fine of two hundred dollars for the violation to date. It said the fine would increase by fifty dollars per day if the structure remained after the deadline, and it said, in a final paragraph that managed to be both formal and faintly threatening, that the association reserved the right to pursue further enforcement, including legal action, if we failed to comply. It was signed by Carolyn Whitmore, with a small, precise signature that looked as if it had been practiced to look authoritative.
I stood there with the letter in my hand and felt, first, confusion, and then a slow, familiar irritation that I recognized from years of dealing with committees and boards, the irritation of a man who has just been told, in writing, that something he knows to be false is now official. Rose took the letter from me, read it herself, and said, very calmly, that there was no such rule. She said it the way a librarian says that a book is not on the shelf, with the certainty of a person who has checked. We had read the covenants when we bought the house, as everyone does, or as everyone says they do, and I remembered them reasonably well, because I am the sort of person who reads the fine print on a telescope warranty and on a homeowners document with the same attention. The covenants talked about fences and sheds and outbuildings, about paint colors and roof materials and the height of hedges, about satellite dishes and clotheslines and the parking of recreational vehicles. They said nothing, as far as either of us could recall, about telescopes, or about backyard equipment that was not a permanent structure, or about sightlines in the sense Carolyn's letter seemed to mean. My telescope was not a building. It was not bolted to a foundation. It lived in a shed when it was not in use, and it rolled out onto the patio on clear nights, the way a grill rolls out or a patio umbrella opens. The camera was smaller than a shoebox. To call them a structure, in the sense of a shed or a pergola, was to stretch the word until it meant whatever the person using it wanted it to mean.
Rose went to the filing cabinet in the study that evening, the one where we keep the house documents in labeled folders, and she pulled out our copy of the covenants, conditions, and restrictions for Willow Ridge Estates, dated and recorded with the county, and we sat at the kitchen table with reading glasses on and went through it page by page, the way we used to go through a difficult passage in a book together, one of us reading aloud and the other following along. We found Section 7, which dealt with architectural control, and we found Section 7.4, which Carolyn had cited, and Section 7.4 said, in plain language, that no shed, outbuilding, or permanent accessory structure exceeding eight feet in height could be erected without prior written approval from the architectural committee. My telescope, on its base, stood just under five feet tall when assembled, and it was not erected in any permanent sense, and it had not been built into the ground. There was no mention of telescopes, no mention of optical equipment, no mention of cameras, and no mention of sightlines as a separate category of violation. There was a separate provision about fences obstructing a neighbor's view from a street, but that provision referred to fences and walls, and our telescope, which sat low in a backyard surrounded by piñon trees, obstructed no one's view of anything except, perhaps, a small patch of sky directly above our own patio.