The Telescope She Tried to Ban on Larkspur Lane

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

David's role was narrower and, in its way, just as important. He would testify as the engineer in the family, the person who had helped me measure the telescope's footprint on the driveway, photograph its position relative to the property line, and preserve the digital files from Lily's phone with their metadata intact. Vasquez walked him through the chain of custody, the dates, the file hashes, the backup copies stored on two separate drives, and David answered with the methodical patience of a man who builds things for a living and knows that a structure stands or falls on whether each joint was made correctly. The neighbours would testify in turn, each to a small, specific piece of the whole. Tom Ellison would testify about the grading trucks and the night he was told to mind his own business. Grace Ellison would testify about the special assessment and the letter that called it an emergency roof repair. Priya Nair would testify about the duplicate invoices, which she had spotted first among the audit papers because she had a bookkeeper's eye for a number that repeats too neatly. Miguel and Ana Torres would testify about what they had seen from their back window, the headlights, the hours, the trucks turning without lights, and Ana would testify in English, slowly and clearly, although Vasquez offered her an interpreter and Ana declined, saying she wanted the jury to hear her own voice. Each witness was a thread, Vasquez told us, and no single thread carried the case, but woven together they made a fabric the defence could not easily tear. My own preparation was the hardest, not because the facts were complicated but because Vasquez insisted I tell them as a witness, not as a narrator, and those are different disciplines. A narrator can wander, can reflect, can pause to describe the light over the San Francisco Peaks at dusk. A witness must answer the question asked, no more and no less, and must not volunteer, must not explain, must not argue with the question. Vasquez drilled me on this in her office and then in a mock courtroom at the county building, where Mark played the defence attorney and asked me questions designed to provoke me. Was it true I had refused to comply with a lawful board order? I learned to answer that I had appealed the order in writing and received no hearing, which was true and which was the whole answer. Was it true I had encouraged my granddaughter to film a private citizen? I learned to answer that I had not been present when Lily began filming, which was true, and to stop there, although every instinct in me wanted to add that Lily had acted bravely and well. Was it true I bore a grudge against Carolyn Whitmore? I learned to pause, to breathe, and to answer that I had disagreed with her decisions and had sought a lawful remedy through the audit and the recall, which was true and which was also, I hoped, dignified. The drills exhausted me in a way physical work never had. I came home from them with a headache behind my eyes and a tightness in my shoulders, and I found myself waking at three in the morning, replaying questions I had answered badly, imagining cross-examination traps I had not anticipated, worrying that a single careless sentence from me could give the defence the opening it needed. Rose knew without my telling her. She began leaving a glass of water on my side of the bed and a small lamp on in the hallway, so that when I woke I would not lie in the dark inventing disasters, and she would put her hand on my back and say, in the plain voice she uses when she means every word, that we had told the truth and the truth did not need my protection, only my honesty. I believed her most nights. Some nights I only wanted to believe her, which is not quite the same thing, and I lay awake listening to the wind in the pines and thinking about the courtroom, and about Carolyn sitting at the defence table, and about Lily sitting in the witness box with every adult in the room watching her.

News in the same category

The Telescope She Tried to Ban on Larkspur Lane

45 Part