The night before the next hearing, Rose and I stayed up late in the backyard, not to observe, but to sit beside the telescope in its covered position and to talk about what came next. The Dobsonian stood silent, its tube capped, its base level, its red light off. Above us, the sky was clear in the way only a Flagstaff autumn sky can be clear, with the Milky Way arcing overhead and the air thin and cold enough to make our breath visible. Rose asked me whether I regretted leaving the camera running that first night, whether a quieter life would have been better than this long, public fight. I thought about the question honestly, because it deserved an honest answer, and I told her that I regretted the stress it had brought to our family, that I regretted that Lily had to learn about lawsuits before she learned about college applications, and that I regretted that neighbours who had once waved across fences now chose sides at the mailbox. But I did not regret the camera, because the camera had not created the grading or the invoices or the missing reserve. It had only recorded what was already happening, and without that recording, the closed land might still be graded at night, the pad might still be rented in secret, and twelve households might still be paying for lighting that never arrived. Rose nodded, took my hand, and said she knew that, but that knowing it did not make the next hearing any easier.
The next hearing was scheduled for a Thursday morning in the county courthouse, a low building with fluorescent lights and wooden benches that smelled faintly of polish. Mark met us in the hallway, carrying two briefcases and a file box, and he briefed us in a low voice while other litigants filed past. Carolyn’s lawyer would argue, he said, that my countersuit should proceed immediately, that my records requests should be limited, and that the audit should be sealed pending trial. Mark would argue the opposite: that the countersuit was retaliatory, that the records belonged to the membership, that the audit was a matter of public concern within the association, and that the court should allow the detective’s investigation to proceed without interference. He warned us that the hearing would be procedural, not dramatic, that there would be no verdict, no testimony from Carolyn or from me, and that the judge would likely set a schedule for discovery, for depositions, and for mediation, a schedule that would stretch into the winter. He also warned us that Carolyn’s lawyer might attempt to introduce a new allegation, something about my telescope violating a light ordinance or about a complaint from a neighbour, in order to shift attention, and that I should not react, should not speak out of turn, and should let him respond.
When we entered the courtroom, Carolyn was already seated at the plaintiff’s table with her lawyer, her posture upright, her expression composed, as if she were still presiding over a board meeting rather than defending a lawsuit she had filed. George Pruitt was seated in the gallery, alone, with his own lawyer beside him, and he did not look at Carolyn. Susan Hale sat two rows behind us, with Tom and Grace Ellison, Priya Nair, and Miguel Torres scattered nearby, a quiet show of support that Mark had not requested but that I felt deeply. Detective Okafor was not present, but Deputy Sarah Nguyen was, in uniform, seated near the door, and her presence reminded me that this case had moved beyond the association’s internal politics into the realm of law enforcement, where records and testimony carried consequences beyond a board vote. The judge, Robert Sandoval, entered, called the case, and asked the lawyers to state their appearances. Mark stood, stated his name and that he represented me, and then Carolyn’s lawyer stood and began his argument, his voice smooth and practiced, describing me as a disgruntled homeowner who had turned a neighbourhood dispute into a crusade, who had weaponized a camera, and who had defamed a dedicated volunteer president. I listened, my hands folded in my lap, Rose beside me, and I thought about the telescope in the backyard, about the nights I had spent aligning it, about the students I had once taught at the planetarium who had looked through a similar instrument and gasped at the rings of Saturn, and I thought about how strange it was that an instrument built to look outward, to the stars, had become the reason I was sitting in a courtroom, listening to a lawyer describe me as a threat to my own community. The judge listened without interruption, then turned to Mark and said, “Mr. Ellison, your response,” and Mark stood, opened his binder to the tab marked audit, and began to speak, his voice steady, his first sentence laying out, in plain terms, the fifty-eight thousand dollars, the forty-one thousand dollars, the two hundred and fifty-three thousand nine hundred dollars, and the pad on the closed land that had been built in secret, at night, with HOA money, while the membership was told the land was untouched, and as he spoke, I saw Carolyn’s composure flicker for the first time, just for a moment, just enough to make me understand that the hearing, and the fight that would follow it, was only beginning, and that what happened next would depend not on who spoke loudest in a community room, but on who could prove, document by document, what had actually been done in the dark behind our houses.