by luck or by strength or by prayer, but by counting, and that the counting had to be done by the person who owned the ranch, because a number counted by another man's hand was a number that could be counted wrong, and a number counted wrong was a number that could cost a ranch its winter. She had laughed at him then, because she had been twenty-eight and newly married and the whole world had seemed like a thing that could be kept by love alone, and he had laughed with her, and then he had taken her hand and put the pencil in it, and he had made her count the sacks in the store herself, and the stacks in the meadow herself, and the cattle in the corral herself, and by the end of that first autumn she could count a store the way he could, and by the time he died she had been keeping the books for six years, and she had never once let another hand write a number in them.
October had come up cold in the mornings and warm in the afternoons, the way October always came up in the Red Creek country, and the cottonwoods along the creek had turned yellow against the blue of the distant mountains, and the cattle had come down from the high pasture to the creek ground, and the twelve hands were out in the far pasture mending the south fence, and the house was quiet, and the kitchen was warm, and Liv stood at the table with her sleeves rolled up and her hands in the dough, and she thought about the winter. The winter was the thing she thought about most, because the winter was the test, and the winter asked the same questions every year, and the questions were simple, and the answers had to be written down, because a woman who kept four hundred cattle through a Colorado winter did not keep them on hope. She kept them on numbers. Oats for the horses. Hay for the cattle. Firewood for the house. Fences for the wind. And the numbers had to be true, because if the numbers were wrong, the winter would find the mistake and the mistake would cost her cattle, and cattle were the ranch, and the ranch was everything she had.
She had put the bread in the oven to rise, and she had set the stew pot on the range, beef and barley and the last of the garden turnips, and the beans were soaking in their bowl, and the table was set for the evening, twelve plates and twelve cups, and she had swept the floor and wiped the shelves, and then she had done the thing she did every autumn, the thing Elias had taught her to do in the first year of their marriage, when they had come up from the valley with nothing but a wagon and a team and a deed to a piece of ground no one else had wanted. She had taken the tally book down from the shelf where it lived, beside her own books, and she had opened it on the kitchen table, and she had begun to count.
The tally book was small and bound in leather, and the leather was worn smooth at the corners from years of handling, and the pages were full of Elias's handwriting, square and plain and careful, the handwriting of a man who wrote every number twice, once in the book and once in his head, because a number written down was a number that would stand. The first page said the year they had come to Red Creek, and the last page said the autumn of 1886, in a hand that was shakier than the rest, because he had been sick by then and he had written it sitting up in bed, and the entry said, "Counted. The store is full. Winter will hold." She had read that entry a hundred times, and every time she read it she thought about the winter that had followed, and about how the winter had held, and about how Elias had not, and about how the store had carried the ranch through the cold months without him, because he had counted it right, and because the counting was the work, and because the work was what saved a ranch.