said the feeding had been done, and the book said the store was empty because the winter had eaten the oats, and the book said the hay had gone the same way, three stacks fed on September twenty-sixth, and the book said the feeding was done, and the book said the numbers were true. But Liv Halvorsen knew the numbers were not true, because she had been on the ranch every day in September, and because she had watched the cattle every day in September, and because the cattle had been on the creek pasture all September, and because no oats had ever been carried to them, and because no hay had ever been carried to them, and because the feeding had never happened, and because the book was lying, and because the book had been written to lie.
She walked back through the days in her mind, the way she walked back through the numbers, one by one, because a day remembered was a day that could be checked, and because a day checked was a day that could not be lied about. On September twentieth she had been mending the corral gate all morning, and she had watched the hands bring the cattle in from the far pasture, and no one had carried a sack of oats anywhere, and the store door had stayed shut all day. On September twenty-second she had ridden the far pasture herself, counting the cattle, and she had come home at dusk, and the yard had been quiet, and the store had been locked. On September twenty-fifth she had been in the kitchen all day, baking bread and mending the harness, and she had watched the yard through the window, and no wagon had come, and no sacks had moved. On September twenty-eighth she had been at the creek with the youngest hand, clearing the brush from the water gate, and she had seen the merchant's wagon on the valley road, loaded high with sacks, heading for town, and she had thought nothing of it at the time, because a merchant's wagon on the valley road was a common sight, and because she had no reason to think the sacks on that wagon were hers. On September thirtieth she had been counting the cattle in the corral, and on October second she had been mending the harness in the barn, and on neither day had anyone fed oats to anything, and on neither day had anyone carried hay to anything, and the book was lying, and the book had been written to lie, and the lie was plain, because the days were plain, and because she had lived them, and because she remembered them.
She sat at the kitchen table with the lamp lit, and she looked at the two books side by side, and she thought about the foreman, and about the two years since Elias died, and about the trust she had given him, and about the daily work she had left to him, and about the fact that he had kept the ranch running, and about the fact that he had hired the hands and ordered the feed and mended the fences, and about the fact that she had never once looked at his book, and about the fact that she had never once counted the store herself, and about the fact that the trust had been a thing she had given freely, and about the fact that the trust had been misplaced. She did not want to believe he had taken the oats and the hay. She did not want to believe anyone on the ranch had taken them. But the numbers did not care what she wanted to believe, and the numbers said that seventy-two sacks and three stacks were gone, and the numbers said that the gone things had been sold, and the numbers said that the sale had been written down as winter feed, and the numbers said that the man who wrote the foreman's book was the man who would have to answer for the numbers.
She thought about how Elias had hired him, six years before, in the autumn of 1882, when the ranch was new and the work was hard and the hands were few, and the foreman had come up from the valley with a strong back and a quiet manner, and Elias had taken him on, and the foreman had worked the ranch through the hard years, and he had worked it through Elias's illness, and he had worked