Robert Moss came across the street just after nine, carrying a folder under his arm and walking with the unhurried step of a man who had spent years in a courtroom and knew that rushing never helped a case. Angela came with him, and Ethan followed with his phone in his hand, already checking the video he had taken the night before. They did not make a fuss about coming over. They just crossed the street the way neighbours do, and Robert stood in my driveway and looked at the car for a long moment without saying anything at all. Then he said, "Caleb, that's a sorry sight, and I'm sorry we're all standing here looking at it." Angela put a hand on June's arm. "We wrote down everything we saw last night, while it was fresh," she said. "Times, what he did first, what he said, where Lorraine's car was. I used to do this for a living, Caleb, and I know what holds up and what doesn't. A memory gets soft after a week. A note written that night doesn't." She opened the folder and showed me pages in her clear, careful handwriting, each page dated and timed, each detail set down in order: the Escalade turning into their driveway at 8 Bluebonnet Ridge Drive, the three doors opening at once, Ethan's phone already recording, Derek Foster standing beside the Lamborghini with something in his hand, the sound of the key going down the paint, the mirror breaking, the tyre going down, Lorraine Foster's car parked down the street with its lights off, and then Derek's voice saying he was just walking past. "Angela," I said, "this is worth more than you know." She shook her head, a small, firm shake. "It's just what we saw," she said. "That's all it needs to be."
Ethan showed me the video on his phone, holding it steady so June and I could see. It was not a polished video. It shook a little at the start, the way a phone video does when someone is getting out of a car in a hurry, but the picture was clear enough, and the sound was clear, and there was Derek Foster beside the yellow car, and there was the scratch appearing, and there was the mirror, and there was my voice and June's voice shouting from the porch, and then Robert's voice, calm and steady, saying, "Son, step away from that car right now," and Angela's voice saying, "Ethan, keep recording." Ethan had kept recording. He had filmed the whole thing, from the Escalade doors opening to Derek backing away with his hands up, and he had also saved the Escalade's own camera footage, the 360-degree view that showed the street from above, the Lamborghini in my driveway, Derek beside it, and Lorraine's car down the street. "I made three copies last night," Ethan said, in the serious tone of a nineteen-year-old who understands exactly how important a thing is. "One on my phone, one on my laptop, and one on a drive I keep in my room. Nobody's going to lose this one, Mr. Hart." I thanked him, and I meant it, and June hugged him, which embarrassed him a little, but he stood still and let her, because he knew she meant it too. Robert looked at me then, and his voice dropped a notch, the way a judge's voice does when he wants you to hear the serious part. "Caleb," he said, "keep your own notes the same way. Every call, every letter, every visit. Date, time, who said what. If this goes where I think it's going, the paper trail will matter as much as the video." I promised him I would, and I already knew I would, because paperwork had been part of my life for thirty-two years, and I trusted paper in a way I did not trust memory or talk.
The repair shop called just before ten, and the man who came out was not a salesman but a technician, a quiet fellow in his forties named Mark who looked at the car the way I would have looked at it, slowly, panel by panel, with a light in his hand. He crouched by the front left wheel and examined the cut in the tyre, he ran his fingers lightly along the scratch without pressing, he looked at the mirror housing and the wiring and the door handle and the trim, and he wrote everything down on a clipboard before he said a word about money. June stood beside me holding my arm, and Angela stood a little back with her folder, watching, because she knew that an estimate is also evidence. When Mark finally stood up and wiped his hands, he spoke plainly, the way a good mechanic speaks. "Mr. Hart, this isn't a buff-and-touch-up job," he said. "That scratch is through the pearl coat and into the primer along the full length of the driver's side. To match Giallo Inti pearl properly, we have to refinish the fender, the door, and the rear quarter as a set, otherwise you'll see the blend line every time the sun hits it. The mirror assembly is a full replacement, housing, glass, motor, and wiring. The tyre is a full replacement, and on this car we check the wheel and the suspension on that corner as well, because a slashed tyre at rest can still hide a bent rim. And we document everything with photographs before we touch a bolt." He gave me the number then, steadily, without apology and without drama, and I wrote it down in my notebook exactly as he said it: thirty-one thousand eight hundred dollars ($31,800). I said it back to him to make sure I had it right. "Thirty-one thousand eight hundred," I repeated. "Yes, sir," he said. "Parts, paint, labour, and the inspection, all in. I'll send the written estimate today, with photographs, line by line." I thanked Mark, and I told him not to start work until I said so, because I wanted the insurance company and the deputies to have the written estimate first, and because I had learned, long ago, that you do not rush a repair when someone else may have to pay for it.